Doing business with Americans? HSBC has some (hilarious) cultural advice

Don’t EVER joke about sex. Expect obscure sports analogies.

Getty Images

So you want to do business with Americans, but worry about overcoming the cultural nuances that separate us from our neighbours to the south? HSBC bank has a handy Expats Guide to doing business in different countries that offers an (unintentionally) hilarious glimpse at the subtle differences between Canadians and Americans, including Canadians’ apparent unease with giving their dinner guests a house tour and Americans’ love of using sports analogies in business negotiations.

Here are some of the cultural traits HSBC recommends you keep in mind when doing business across the border (and we are quoting):

ETIQUETTE FAUX PAS

Canada:

  • Avoid the “V” for victory and the “thumbs-down” gestures.
  • Use your entire hand to point, not just your finger.
  • Don’t compare Canada with the US

U.S.:

  • [Avoid] anything that might be misinterpreted as sexual harassment
  • [Don't] boast about your accomplishments and achievements, salary, income or belongings
  • [Don't] stand too close to someone you’re speaking with, lest you impose on their sense of personal space

 CULTURE

Canada:

  • People from the Atlantic Provinces (Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island and Newfoundland) tend to be a bit more reserved and provincial.
  • Ontario is Canada’s business hub, and its inhabitants are generally businesslike and conservative.
  • Western Canada (Alberta, Manitoba and Saskatchewan) tends to be open, friendly and relaxed.
  • British Columbia can be thought of as being somewhat unconventional, and often is touted as the future of the nation.
  • Quebec’s people have a proud French cultural identity, and tend to be highly independent.
  • People from the north retain a strong pioneer spirit.

U.S.:

Americans are raised from childhood to see themselves as distinct, separate individuals who create their own destinies and are responsible for their own lives. As such, they consider themselves accountable for their decisions. They view themselves as independent and self-reliant, and for this reason can appear self-centred to those from less individualistic cultures.

ATTENDING A DINNER PARTY

Canada:

  • Be punctual, though 15 minutes late is fine for a small gathering or party.
  • Offer to help prepare before or clean up after.
  • Don’t ask for a house tour, since Canadians are private and only allow guests in their public rooms as a rule.
  • Don’t rest elbows on the table, and always keep your hands visible.
  • Continental style reigns, with fork in left hand and knife in right, though American style (switching your fork from hand to hand) is permissible.

U.S.:

  • Be on time for dinner, and no more than 10 minutes late for small gatherings.
  • You may be told to make yourself at home, and you’re expected to do so, and to ask for anything you require.
  • You may be given a tour of the house.
  • American table manners involve holding the fork in the right hand and using it to eat. Hold it tines up. The knife cuts and spreads things. To use it, switch the fork to your left hand. To eat, switch your fork back to your right hand.

BUSINESS MEETINGS

Canada:

  • Most Canadians prefer business to be concise, and meetings begin with a minimal amount of small talk. However, there may be more time spent on relationship-building in Quebec.
  • Meeting with Anglophones are more democratic. Meetings with Francophones may include less involvement of lower level employees.
  • Feelings are not considered important in business. It is better to state information with the words “I think” rather than “I feel”.

U.S.:

  • Meetings generally start with little or no small talk.
  • Americans may be blunt when countering ideas that others put forward, and interruptions may be common in an animated discussion.
  • When Americans say “Yes” or “No” they mean it. “Maybe” means “It might happen”; it does not mean “No”.

BUSINESS NEGOTIATIONS

Canada:

  • Communication is generally direct. Canadians have no difficulty saying “no.”
  • Strive to create compromises.
  • French Canadians will carefully analyze every detail of a proposal, regardless of how minute.

U.S.:

  • American negotiators can become frustrated if too much time is devoted to relationship building rather than negotiating.
  • Unlike many cultures where eloquence is important, Americans are more concerned with making their point.
  • It may at times seem that American negotiations are run by lawyers. This is because there is strict government legislation concerning many facets of business.

COMMUNICATION STYLES

Canada:

Communication is moderately indirect. Although most Canadians can disagree, they prefer to do so with tact and diplomacy. They prefer to maintain an understated demeanour. Their communication style is pragmatic and relies on common sense rather than aggression. If you come from a more direct culture, you may wish to soften your demeanour and tone so as not to appear threatening.

  • Greetings tend to be relatively informal, which demonstrates Canadians’ belief in egalitarianism.
  • Canadians enjoy debating issues. Being able to argue your position with informed opinion will help you gain respect.
  • Making eye contact during conversation adds to the credibility of the communication. Sustained eye contact throughout a conversation is expected.

U.S.:

For the most part, Americans do not hesitate to ask direct questions. These are not meant to be offensive. Their reliance on speaking concisely and relying on facts can make American speech seem rude, aggressive, blunt or impatient to people from cultures that are more relationship-oriented. Since many Americans speak only English, they are not always sensitive to the challenges someone faces when communicating in a foreign language. Americans often used sporting analogies that are not easily understood. The following are ones frequently used in business:

  • Ballpark figure: Give a good estimate
  • Play hardball: Compete well
  • Drop the ball: Make a serious mistake
  • Monday morning quarterback: Someone who tells you what you should have done after the fact.

 




Browse

Doing business with Americans? HSBC has some (hilarious) cultural advice


  1. Quebec’s people have a proud French cultural identity, and tend to be highly independent.”

    Except when it comes to money from the rest of the country.

    • That is all that you got from this hilarious, possibly tongue-in-cheek presentation? They could have added ‘not very bright’ and tend to be biased about those not exactly like their perfect selves.

      • Heh. I hope it’s tongue-in-cheek. A lot of these are “Funny cause it’s true”, but I had to laugh at the Americans “…consider themselves accountable for their decisions” part. Anyone who looks at how bogged down the legal system is with bogus lawsuits would have a hard time taking this observation seriously.

      • Whom does `their` refer to, Americans or Quebecers?

    • Americans should see that there is ETHNIC Cleansing in Quebec. French, white only in Quebec.
      Quebec FASCISM is alive and well.

      • Please expand on your little theory….

  2. Well, Americans are self-starters. and many Canadians, depending on where you live, are not.

  3. HSBC is hong kong bank, isn’t it? I lived in South Korea and they have similar culture to Chinese – these guides on how people are different make me laugh. North Americans are basically viewed as hooligans by people in Orient, at least, because we are very individual and don’t respond to peer/society pressure.

    • Huh, I always thought it was British based, but you are correct. Just goes to show how companies use acronyms [that don't stand for anything anymore] these days to hide from word associations that may be taken negatively. Just look at KFC.

      • It’s British based. Hong Kong used to be Bristish, you see…

    • HSBC – Hong Kong Singapore Banking Corporation. For all intents and purposes it’s a British bank though (and doubly so since they moved their HQ to London in the ’90s) as it was founded at a time when those places were part of the British Empire.

      • Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation.

    • I’ve been living in Beijing for a year and a half and I’ve gone to Seoul twice and I would say that the cultural differences can be pretty large. They eat different things, they have different political views, they do business differently, they have different kinds of educations… Moreover, the cultural differences between different places in China are pretty great as well. I wold say that It’s the same as the differences within Europe if not more.

    • HSBC, regardless of where it is “based”, is a global bank. Hence the need for primers on business, negotiations and social gatherings in various cultures.
      Yes, these are mostly funny because of their reliance on stereotypes, but if you have an early morning conference call with someone in Toronto and know nothing about Canada, these could still be useful. Especially the points under communications and negotiation styles.

    • Oh, we respond to peer/society pressure, all right! It’s just not in the way they want. Pressure has this tendence for us to say, in effect, “Screw you!”

  4. When did the Canada represent beaver get replaced with a moose!!!

    • This is all part of the Harper Gov’t(TM) slant on our new and better Canada. God help us , or to be in sync Gott in Himmel !

  5. You spelled “border” wrong (“when doing business across the boarder”). Most of these aren’t “hilarious”…they’re just accurate.

  6. Newfoundlanders reserved???? In what universe? They are outspoken, politically incorrect, gregarious and incredibly hospitable.

    • You are equating reserved with introverted, and the two are not the same. They are reserved, preferring to keep the conversation light and jovial and avoiding personal matters, also avoiding being direct or critical.

  7. Do they have one for interacting with terrorists? Mexican drug cartels, perhaps?

  8. They probably could have separate sections for English vs French Canadians, since there really is a lot of difference.

  9. Who the hell wrote this crap anyway?

    Musta been someone who hasn’t been in either Canada OR the US

  10. This is all Bunk!

  11. What alot of bunk, this is stereotypes to the extreme. Quebec independent to last cent of Alberta’s tax dollars!

  12. “People from the north retain a strong pioneer spirit”

    Bwahahaha!

  13. One thing I learned on arriving in Canada is “Maybe” is Canadian for “No.” Most Canadians I’ve interacted with think saying “No” is delivering bad news and that is not polite.
    No wonder HSBC had to launder money, they haven’t got a clue.

  14. I can think of a lot of great descriptions of Atlantic Canadians and the word “reserved” does not occur in any of them. I’m from Ontario and whenever I go there I feel like a potted plant.

Sign in to comment.