The youth unemployment myth—take two

If anything, underemployment is the issue a new report shows


A new report (opens a PDF) from the Certified General Accountants Association of Canada sheds further light on why we shouldn’t really be pitying the youth. (For Stephen Gordon’s take on this, see here.)

Workers ages 15-24 (formally “the youth” for statisticians and economists) had an easier time during the latest recession than they did in the previous two. At roughly 15 per cent, the peak unemployment rate for youth in 2008-2009 was considerably lower than the levels seen in 1990 and 1981-82, which stood at over 17 and 19 per cent respesctively. (Don’t be shocked that the youth unemployment rate is so much higher among youth than older demographics, that’s normal in developed economies.)

Besides,  spells of unemployment for those ages 15-24 tend to last much less than for older workers. This, as the chart below shows, is a historical trend but it continues to hold true:

*Source: Statistics Canada’s LFS custom tabulation, CGA-Canada calculations.

And the youngest workers are doing remarkably well in the recovery in terms of wages, too.  Youth seized some 18,800 high-quality jobs between October 2009 and October 2011, according to the report:

CGA also debunks the myth that struggling boomers are crowding out the youth labour market by taking up jobs that typically employ teens and those in their early twenties. Last year, the youth unemployment rate in these types of occupations was lower than the historical average. At the same time, professions that saw an influx of older workers did not see a corresponding rise in youth unemployment, leading the report’s authors to conclude that: “what may seem to be an assertive expansion of the older workers’ presence in the labour market is, in fact, a mere reflection of demographic changes.”

If anything, the real issue for Canadians entering the labour market today is underemployment. Although education levels among those ages 15 to 24 have steadily improved in the past decade, the rate of youth employed in low-skilled jobs has been holding steady:

But, far from being a “youth problem,” underemployment seems to be a pretty generalized issue that afflicts all age groups to roughly the same extent.






The youth unemployment myth—take two

  1. Very good article showing the degree that the plight of young people (like me) entering the work force has been exaggerated. I would be very interested to see a comparison of living expenses vs. wages for young workers added to this.

    • living expenses vs. wages.


      12years ago a loaf of bread was 200%less then it is now.

      minimum wage, (which most of these youth are getting), has not gone up 200%.

      though rent as not also gone up 200%. iz up alot in many places where there is work.
      underemployment which the article mentions in passing is a MASSIVE
      ISSUE. much worse. also they don’t bother to mention that alot of youth,
      have just stoped looking for work.(or have not had a job in the time
      before one laps into “not looking for work”, all statics and
      manipulation of that core number and thus are not counted in the labour
      market. total number of youth who do not have work would be more
      interesting. (and not just “unemployed”. or are in the underground
      economy. (freelance work, cash jobs etc). likely don’t pay tax, but dont
      look for work. but are likely rather poor.

      • Language skills are important – especially when looking for work.

        • msg bords are not formal insatutionzzzzzzzzzz babyz. soryz

          • If you don’t bother using manners at your kitchen table, you’ll forget to use them at a dinner party.

  2. Is it not also the case that, because of the demographic shifting, the youth category occupies a larger share of the total work force now than it did in 1990?

  3. Erica Alini ends the first paragraph with: “We shouldn’t really be pitying the youth.”

    And then ends the second paragraph with: “Don’t be shocked that the youth unemployment rate is so much higher among youth than older demographics, that’s normal in developed economies.”

    It’s normal in underdeveloped economies too, so what’s the base here?

  4. Frankly, any of these kinds of discussions and analysis mean nothing if you don’t bother to look at things such as the growth in insecure contract work and people who want something more than part time employment. The numbers for that show a youth unemployment rate of nearly twenty per cent.