11

19 UBC students arrested at bonfire protest

Police make arrests after protestors block fire department


 

Nearly 20 people at the University of British Columbia face a series of charges including assaulting a police officer and resisting arrest after a protest escalated into a confrontation and arrests. The students are now asking for a public inquiry into the incident.

Police arrested 19 students rallying Friday in support of a peer who was blocking a fire hose being used to douse a protest bonfire. About 100 people with Students for a Democratic Society and Trek Park for People gathered outside UBC’s Student Union Building to demonstrate against the redevelopment of a nearby grassy knoll, a popular student hangout, for a bus loop.

RELATED CONTENT

Arrests of 19 students “most disturbing”: UBC VP

Update: UBC investigating mass student arrests

Making a mountain out of a knoll hill

Steve Klein, of the Students for a Democratic Society, says police used excessive force, aggravated a peaceful situation and engaged in a process of misinformation with the media following an anti-development rally at the university on Friday. Klein says the students will be contacting the B.C. Civil Liberties Union and are considering a complaint to the province’s police complaint commissioner.

A release from the society said a woman was told she was violating a bylaw by blocking the hose. “(The woman) was grabbed by an RCMP officer and thrown to the ground, pinned, and handcuffed. Her face was literally shoved in a puddle of mud while an RCMP officer sat on top of her,” the release said, describing it as an “uncalled act of police aggression.” The society said another student was immediately arrested for questioning the police action.

Watch the video from the protest:

hIzPNHbXTuE&hl

The release said the detentions led to students forming a human chain in protest. As a result, the release said, 26 students were arrested after 30 police cars from throughout Metro Vancouver arrived on the scene.

However, RCMP Cst. Annie Linteau with RCMP’s E Division said only 19 people were arrested at the scene. She said they received a call from campus security and the Vancouver fire department for assistance of dealing with the large crowd and bonfire.

“Upon their arrival, the firefighters deemed the fire to be unsafe and asked for our assistance to move the protesters,” she said. When they protesters were told to move, Linteau said “they banded together against the police and prevented the fire crews from putting out the fire.” At this point officers from Vancouver and Richmond detachments were called in the deal with “combative” protesters.

When one man was arrested and put in a police cruiser, the protesters banded around the car. Police then made their arrests.

The Alma Mater Society vice-president of administration Tristan Markle called on university president Stephen Toope to condemn the arrests. He called the arrests a “collective punishment” for students who have been protesting development on the campus.

Steve Klein from the Students from Democratic Society said protesters confronted security after they were holding a female on the ground in a puddle of water as they were trying to put out the fire. He said they tried negotiating with the officer to let the woman go. “He finally stood her up and eight people locked arms around her and said that this was a complete overreaction,” Klein said, in a phone interview, adding that they spoke with the officer for about an hour.

The woman wasn’t arrested but the same people who were negotiating with the police, surrounded a car where a fellow protester was inside, under arrest. “We danced around the police cruiser and sang songs for maybe an hour,” he said. “We were careful not to touch the police cruiser or anything else.”

At this point, more officers were called in and the situation escalated. Klein counted 18 police cruisers, two paddy wagons, a police van and several undercover police car. He said the commanding officer at the scene would not allow the people surrounding the car to negotiate with them and the crowd started to get upset. It was then that the arrests were made.

“It seemed to me like it was inexperienced police officers escalating the situation rather than diffusing it and letting it get completely out of hand,” Klein said.

-with a report from CP


 

19 UBC students arrested at bonfire protest

  1. “He said the commanding officer at the scene would not allow the people surrounding the car to negotiate with them” – Steve Klein, you do not with police officers, you cooperate. If you have started an illegal fire and then don’t cooperate when the fire department tries to put it out, you can’t cut a deal with the police saying… ‘well, on second thought, maybe you can put out the fire, but only if you release the people you already arrested.’ You cooperate, and let the police and the fire department get their job done.

    “We were careful not to touch the police cruiser or anything else.”
    – it doesn’t matter. You are still blocking the police cruiser from leaving the scene, which is still obstruction of justice. You can’t block a police cruiser from going somewhere for an hour and not expect the police to arrest you.

    The police conducted their duties professionally in the face of hostile and belligerent protesters. There was no ‘police brutality.’ This reeks of spin and attention mongering almost as badly as the UofT protest a couple of weeks back. Knollies, stop trying to pawn everything off on “the Man.”

  2. Personally, I’ve got little sympathy for those who’d screw with fire crews. No matter whether you think the fire is safe or not, no matter whether it’s in protest of something incontravertably heinous or not, do not get in the way of fire crews. They know more about safety and about fire behavior than you do. If they say put it out, put the damn thing out.

    From this article, it sounds like the SDS doesn’t even have its facts straight for simple things like how many were arrested, so that makes me seriously question their interpretation of the rest of the events.

  3. *correction to my above post – it should read “Steve Klein, you do not *negotiate* with police officers”… accidentally left out a critical word there

  4. It is almost funny to read the comments from the protestors. They seem to be oblivious to how civil disobedience works. The point of these campaigns is the belief that there are some causes for which people are willing to give up their freedom. When one commits civil disobedience one is breaking the law and for that there are consequences. If you aren’t willing to face the consequences don’t conduct the civil disobedience.

  5. Ladies and Gentlemen, mark this date on your calenders – I agree with ThinkOrThwim :) (though I still think the name is lame)

    ‘Peaceful protest’ implies acknowledging and cooperating with the civil authorities. The moment you defy the police, fire department or other legitimate authority is the moment your protest stops being peaceful, and the civil disobedience begins.

    Speaking of, I can’t but think of this picture…

    (here’s hoping my dirty html works in the comment box)

  6. It is well known at UBC that the Students for a Democratic Society is a front organization for the NDP.

    Such a protest was orchestrated by the NDP to intimidate the students and faculty at UBC.

    Jack leave the students at UBC alone …

  7. That’s one of the most amazing things I’ve ever read. The protest at the knoll was engineered by the NDP to scare the students and faculty at UBC?

    I’ll bet Jack Layton’s been organizing the protests against the Olympic torch run to scare the bobsledders.

  8. “For shame, for shame!”

    Methinks the UofT protesters flew out to UBC for round 2.

  9. Peter Butler, Im just going to assume that was sarcasm and that your not actually misinformed enough to think such a thing.

    Speaking as a member of the UBC NDP club’s executive, I can say we did no such thing and in fact, numerous members of the executive have, outside of their role in the club, criticized the protesters.

  10. Pingback: UBC Farm now on the Map: Is the Farm Finally ‘Saved’? « Environmental Communications

  11. Pingback: More Than Acceptable: UBC during the presidency of Stephen Toope, Vol. 2 | Justin McElroy: A guy who writes things.

Sign in to comment.