Carleton cancels Shinerama; says disease only affects “white people”

Students say decision is “disgusting” and “disappointing”


Carleton University Students’ Association is cancelling Shinerama, the school’s popular fundraiser for cystic fibrosis, after the council said the fatal disease is not “inclusive” enough.

The motion, which passed 17 to 2 at the association’s Nov. 24 meeting, read: “Whereas Cystic fibrosis has been recently revealed to only affect white people, and primarily men…Be it resolved that: CUSA discontinue its support of this campaign.”

Read: Carleton president calls on CUSA to revisit decision

Past Carleton student leaders “horrified” at Shinerama cancellation

Coleman’s free advice to CUSA and Carleton students

Vote: What do you think about Carleton’s recent decision to stop fundraising for Shinerama?

Shinerama fundraising takes place during orientation week and has been happening at Carleton University for nearly 25 years. As a result, the school has raised almost $1 million for the Canadian Cystic Fibrosis Foundation.Only one day after the controversial vote, hundreds of Carleton students have flocked online to protest the cancellation of an event they say is incredibly important to the charitable life of the school.

“Students are incredibly upset about this,” said Nick Bergamini, a third-year journalism student who sits on the council and also recently started a Facebook group protesting the move.

“The ones who are the most upset are the ones whose friends or family have cystic fibrosis. They’re upset that a group of small-minded individuals are playing politics at the expense of the charity.”

Hear Nick Bergamini in conversation with 580 CFRA

The website of the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation says the disease is most common in Caucasians but can affect all races. According to Wikipedia, “approximately 1 in 25 people of European descent and 1 in 22 people of Ashkenazi Jewish descent is a carrier of a cystic fibrosis mutation. Although CF is less common in these groups, approximately 1 in 46 Hispanics, 1 in 65 Africans and 1 in 90 Asians carry at least one abnormal CFTR gene.”

Wikipedia also notes that, “cystic fibrosis is diagnosed in males and females equally. For unclear reasons, males tend to have a longer life expectancy than females.” It is the most common fatal genetic disease affecting young Canadians, with an estimated 3,500 people living with the condition.

Shinerama began in 1964 as a shoe-shining campaign and is now Canada’s largest post-secondary fundraiser. High-energy events are held at nearly 60 university and college campuses, where more than 35,000 student volunteers shine shoes, wash cars, run raffles and barbeques, and sing songs on street corners.

Since the event’s cancellation was announced, numerous online groups sprung up in protest, calling the move “disgraceful”, “disgusting”, and “disappointing”. Many expressed dismay at the lack of consultation of the student body regarding the decision.

“This is the weirdest day that I’ve ever had at Carleton,” says graduate student Ashley Darch, who also attended the school as an undergraduate.

She says the Ottawa campus is abuzz with news of Shinerama’s cancellation. “CUSA usually does all kinds of talking and then they never do anything. Now people are walking around campus saying, ‘Did this really just happen?'”

She says the decision came out of nowhere, which was a surprise coming from the typically vocal association. “People are angry that the tradition of Shinerama was scrapped without any consultation,” she says. “But it’s the whole white male preamble thing that has thrown everyone off.”

On the Facebook group set up by Bergamini, Meera Chander, the CUSA public affairs councilor who seconded the motion, defends the council’s actions and distances herself from the controversial sentence regarding race.

“I do not support the whereas clauses involved in the motion. I do however support the spirit of the motion, in that we should be able to give back to other charities as well,” she writes. “There is no reason to blow the situation out of proportion.”

Other angry Carleton students who are posting on the same online board say they hope CUSA is getting the signal that their constituents need to be fairly represented.

“The motion had no notice, most councilors had no time to consult with any of their constituents and yet they wholeheartedly passed it,” writes student Andrew Monkhouse. “The motion could have been tabled…to allow for consultations but they chose not to.”

The online back-and-forth has reached such a fever pitch that one CUSA councilor wrote an apology to Bergamini’s Facebook group, saying that he knows of six councilors who would be willing to support an emergency meeting of the council in order to assuage student outrage.

“I am really and truly sorry,” writes Michael Monks, councillor for business on CUSA. “I was at the meeting that night and I voted for this motion…information suggested that the orientation volunteers desired to select an alternative charity. After reading this groups discussion I can see that this was not the case.”

Former CUSA president James Pratt commented on the situation as well, saying that race had nothing to do with the association’s move to support another charity.

“There have been discussions about changing charities because it has been over 20 years and a million dollars raised,” he says. Pratt says it was unfortunate that Donnie Northrop, the councilor who wrote the sentence concerning race, phrased the sentence the way he did, but that it should not rule out the possibility of switching charities.

Badly phrased or not, Darch says she’s concerned at the effect this imbroglio will have on the school.

“I think there’s going to be some backlash from the public,” she says. “It’s an example of reverse discrimination but it’s also just in really bad taste.”



Carleton cancels Shinerama; says disease only affects “white people”

  1. There’s something that’s been really bothering me about this story… so what if CF only affected white people (primarily males)? It is a horrible, life-threatening, disease that affects thousands of Canadians, and likely millions world-wide. Why does it make sense to stop funding research for it because some people are, by virtue of their genetics, much less likely to be afflicted with it? Should we then also stop funding for sickle-cell anemia, breast cancer, prostate cancer, Tay-Sachs disease, Huntington’s disease, AIDS… because certain segments of the population cannot (or are unlikely to) be afflicted by them? Are these student leaders so selfish that the cannot understand that the purpose of charities is not to feel good about yourself, but to help those who are in need?

  2. Pingback: Shinerama fallout hits Carleton U : Macleans OnCampus

  3. Pingback: CUSA & Cystic Fibrosis Fundraiser « DIALOGIC Mediation Services

  4. Pingback: “Decisions are made by those who show up”: The CUSA/Shinerama Affair « CYNICISM FALLS ASLEEP

  5. There are countless great causes out there to support. However, the ratinale to change the cause just because it has always been the same doesn’t make any sense to me. Why offend & disadvatage a great cause such as this? If it has always been the same, then it is a great tradition, and even more reason to leave it alone. To Donnie Northrop: the disease affects more than just white males, and last time I checked, the haven’t found the cure, so the continued support of Shinerama would really help.

  6. If anyone claims to be a democrat, one should find this decision viable, representative and an easy-to-swallow-a pill. A simple litmus test to one’s democratic integrity.

    How often, if at all, do we hear the Canadian Public pushing the government to contribute to the discoverly of Malaria Vaccine. No one even talks about it. The assumption behind the silence, is: “Because it does not affect ‘us'” Canadians love hiding behind unstated premises and enjoying the good unearned reputation through media & propaganda.

    The world is changing we snooz we lose, wake up! Decisions cannot always be made to satisfy our fragile yet unchanging appalling nature. Let’s face it. Nothing personal and no reason to neigh out loud!

    Wake up Jeffs!!!

  7. *sigh*

    How can even the commenters say that CF is a male disease when the article says it affects both genders equally but kills women much more quickly? (especially Jewish women apparently)

    Like the commenter above me said, tackling malaria would be a good idea, especially since part of the reason why it’s ravaging Africa is because environmental radicals urged their first world governments to put pressure on 3rd world governments to stop using insecticides (to kill mosquito carriers).

    I guess we’d rather see infants die of malaria than have them grow into old age and possibly contract cancer from exposure to insecticides (which are only significantly cancerous when farmers decide to carpet-bomb their crops with it, not when it’s sprayed lightly in your house to kill mosquitoes)

  8. Pingback: CUSA reinstates Shinerama campaign, Donnie Northrup resigns : Macleans OnCampus

  9. Pingback: White people are not discriminated against by Carleton University students. « Restructure!

  10. Pingback: Back behind the mic … for a day « Nick Taylor-Vaisey

  11. Why does Brittany Smyth still serve? Not only was she was not fired, she said the incident was “blown out of proportion?….” Very curious to see what would have happened if a man had canceled a breast cancer benefit?…

  12. Hi, I can’t even believe this article is out there somewhere, and people are reading them now. This is sexist and racist, no doubt. Sorry to burst their bubble, but according to a Childwiki article, indeed, almost 1 out of 3600 Caucasian infants are born with this condition. However there are still risks because 1 out of 17000 African-Americans babies also have this disease.
    I hope I highlighted the most important words enough. People can be so unfair sometimes.

Sign in to comment.