13

Help! My prof is on strike!

Should students be scared when faculty threaten to walk out?


 

Labour unrest at Western and Carleton have, no doubt, students there worried. And as the academic year rolls on, more faculty associations across the country may reach tense periods in their bargaining processes. Could my school be next? But since students are not always familiar with the mechanics of such negotiations, the uncertainty can be unnerving. What follows is a brief outline of what goes on to help students feel a bit less uncertain.

At nearly every university in Canada, professors and other academics are members of a local faculty association, and in most cases those associations are legally unions according to provincial labour laws. For professors, most of those locals are part of a national union, The Canadian Association of University Teachers.

Faculty associations negotiate collective agreements with their university administrations and those agreements govern much of the academic workings of the university. Students may not be aware of it, but everyday things like the numbers of students in their classes may, in fact, be determined by the university’s contract with its faculty.

These contracts are made only for a few years at a time since neither side wants to be bound to one set of rules for too long — new problems may arise, after all. So, around the time the old agreement is set to run out, the two sides meet to try to negotiate a new deal. Often the changes are minor, but there are usually important things that both sides want to alter. Salaries, for example, are almost always on the table, but, as the recent disputes at Western and Carleton show, things like tenure and promotion can take centre stage.

Sometimes both sides agree within a few months to new terms and a contract is signed without much conflict. Just as often, though, negotiations drag on, impasses are reached, and things get tense. At some point, the faculty association’s executive may call a vote asking members to authorize a strike should they deem one necessary. Students should be aware that calling a vote for a strike mandate like this is very common in such negotiations and is nothing to be alarmed about. A strike vote is not a decision to strike; it’s only an authorization to call a strike if necessary. In fact, the strike vote may actually help resolve the problems because it shows the administration that faculty are serious.

When the vote is called, faculty association members typically vote in favour of a strike because if they vote against it, their bargainers lose almost all their power: they have to show the administration that, at the end of the day, they are willing to walk. That is the only real power faculty associations have.

If no agreement can be reached — and pending a variety of mediations that may be mandated by provinical laws — faculty may strike. They leave the university, cease their teaching and typically set up picket lines on campus. Depending on the particulars, the university itself may remain open so that students can go to the library, work in computer labs and so on, but those details will vary from one university to the next. Check the web sites of the university and of the faculty association itself to get information about your case.

If they do feel the need to walk out, associations typically try to arrange strikes for a time that will cause maximum disruption to the university’s operations so that the administration has plenty of motivation to make a deal. Faculty generally do not strike in the summer because the university can simply let them stay away without losing much revenue or causing a public uproar. Consequently, many associations try to time their job actions for the middle of the term to create fear that exams and courses might be in jeopardy if the situation is not resolved.

Does this sound like students are being used? They are. Associations want students and parents and members of the community to rally together and say “get those profs back to work for our kids’ sake!” which pressures the university to cave in to faculty demands.

At the same time, what is good for faculty is often good for students in the long run. If faculty win higher salaries at the bargaining table, it may mean recruiting better profs in the future. If they get better rules for academic freedom, it may mean better teaching because instructors are not worried about what they can and cannot say. If they get smaller class sizes, you may get more personal attention in your next course.

The good news is that for all the anxiety, faculty strikes are not usually very long (typically weeks, not months). So far as I know, no Canadian university has ever lost a term or semester due to a strike. So if there is a talk of a strike where you go to school, don’t panic. The strike is not likely to happen. If it does, it likely won’t be long, and by the time there is another one, you will have graduated and moved on.


 

Help! My prof is on strike!

  1. Please note that most undergraduate students have far more contact with contract, or part-time, professors than they do with full-time tenured faculty. Most contract instructors are part of either unions which are unique to their university (e.g. the Association of Part-Time Professors of the Univesity of Ottawa, APTPUO), or part of a non-academic union such as the Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE). The Canadian Association of University Teachers does NOT represent part-time/contract instructors. Similarly, Teaching Assistants also are heavily involved with the undergraduate student experience and they are not members of CAUT either.

  2. Shelley, you are right inasmuch as the situation is more complex than I make it sound.

    The situation seems to vary broadly from one university to the next. At my university, most full-time contract and some part time instructors are part of the same faculty association as regular faculty (CBUFA, a CAUT local). In small universities like mine, most student contact is with tenured and tenure-track faculty, but you are right to say that at larger institutions it may not always be so.

    Thus complex situations can arise when some instructors are on strike and others are not. I believe this has been the situation at York on more than one occasion.

  3. “The Canadian Association of University Teachers does NOT represent part-time/contract instructors.”

    That would be true, except for the part-time/contract instuctors at: Acadia, Alberta, Algoma, Bishop’s, Brandon, British Columbia, Calgary, Lakehead, Laurentian, Moncton, Mount Allison, New Brunswick, Nipissing, Northern British Columbia, Nova Scotia College of Art and Design, Queen’s, Prince Edward Island, Regina, St Thomas, Western, Wilfred Laurier and Windsor. CAUT also includes the CUPE locals at Toronto and McMaster. The list is not exhaustive.

    Now: what’s your point?

  4. Hello,

    I’m a first year student at Carleton and I’m not exactly sure of what to make of the whole situation. What happens to students if the strike goes ahead? Are the exams pushed back to a later date, is the whole semester done away with together? Is tuition refunded and are students compensated?

    • Kaitlyn, your university administration would decide the specifics, and, of course, it would depend on how long the strike was, and so on. But, as I said, I don’t believe any Canadian university has ever lost a term to a strike. If the strike is short, the university may say the shortened term is good enough and let profs cover the remaining material as best they can. If the strike is long, they may extend the term and push back exams.

      When CBU faculty went out for five weeks in 2000, the term was extended but students were also given the option of dropping any of their courses for a full refund if they wanted.

  5. “The Canadian Association of University Teachers does NOT represent part-time/contract instructors.”

    In addition to the list cited above, it is important to note that at one of the universities mentioned in this story as currently have a strike vote by faculty (Western), part-time faculty are represented by the SAME union (a CAUT affiliate) as full-time faculty (about 1500 members in all). If we walk, it shuts down most of the teaching on campus. The staff association here also just held a strike vote (95%). Teaching assistants at Western are represented by a separate union (PSAC), also currently bargaining with their employer.

  6. What about the strike that York just went on last year? That was nearly a term wasn’t it?

    • York did have a very long strike, but it is my understanding that while a lot of time was lost, students did end up getting the credits for courses in which they were registered. That seems to be part of the gist of this story:

      http://www.cbc.ca/canada/toronto/story/2009/01/24/york-strike.html

      Can anyone from York give more detail?

  7. Hello,

    I have been searching online to see if there are any updates on whether or not Carleton faculty will go on strike. Does anyone know what the current situation is?

    • Travis, one good source (though obviously not entirely objective) is the faculty association’s own web site. There’s quite a bit of up to date information here:

      http://www.caut.ca/cuasa/Information.html

      From what I gather, they are in the final stages of negotiation, so you should be hearing more soon.

  8. Thank you Todd, this was very helpful, I also saw posters up at school yesterday saying that TA’s and one other group (I forget what they were called) at Carleton are also having votes to go on strike, although that wouldn’t be as bad as the faculty striking.

  9. Refunds were given to York students, but there was a catch. Rather than provide students with a monetary refund, the refund amount was simply applied to the following years’ tuition.

    I have heard rumours that York faculty are in a position to strike AGAIN this month. Any truth to that??

  10. Sarah, I haven’t heard anything about York’s faculty going out. YUFA members (1400 members of CAUT) have a contract until 2012, but I don’t know enough about York to know if there are smaller unions whose contract might be up.

    The situation at UWO is getting down to the wire, so maybe your source confused York and Western.

Sign in to comment.