Student leaders shouldn't focus on Israel - Macleans.ca
 

Student leaders shouldn’t focus on Israel

There’s enough to worry about right there on campus


 

socialistalternative/Flickr

Sean Wilson, a board member of the University of Regina Students’ Union, says that student leaders should be focused on things like tuition, residences and public transit. Recently, they’ve often been focused on the Middle East instead. Not on those killed by their own government in Syria, the sexual minorities mistreated by Iran or women subjugated by Saudi Arabia. No, they’ve been debating whether to join such international power brokers as Lenny Kravitz and the Teachers’ Union of Ireland in their commitments to not buy Israeli products or host Israeli academics.

Big deal right? I would argue yes, and not just because these student unions are taking sides.

Wilson was one of the few dissenters among 60 or so students present near the end of last year’s URSU Annual General Meeting (most had left by then) when the student union resolved to:

“Join student organizations around the globe by endorsing the 2005 call for Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions from Palestinian civil society; and Commit to identifying and divesting from companies that support or profit from Israeli war crimes, occupation and oppression; and Affirm that students have a vital role in supporting struggles for social justice, and stand in solidarity with Palestinians’ struggle for self determination and freedom.”

The statement probably didn’t have much effect on Israel but it had a powerful impact on Wilson. “Pretty much from the moment it passed I said, ‘next year I’m going to come back and put forward a motion to repeal it,'” he says, adding that it cemented his decision to run for a board seat.

At the time, Wilson (who isn’t Jewish) suspected most students had no clue what was going on. But a lot more probably noticed when Conservative MP Randy Hoback condemned URSU in Canada’s Parliament. Last week Hoback rose to address the issue once again after URSU repealed last year’s decision following months of advocacy work by Wilson and his allies. Said Hoback:

“Mr. Speaker, I rise today to congratulate the University of Regina Students’ Union for ending its involvement in the anti-Semitic boycott, divestment and sanctions movement against the State of Israel. The U of R Students’ Union is now out of the anti-Semitism business, and most promising, the movement to end anti-Semitism funding in Canadian universities is growing.”

Hoback’s right that a backlash is growing. The University of Manitoba Students’ Union decided this month to stop funding Students Against Israeli Apartheid, one of BDS’s promoters. Then again, BDS is growing too. The York Federation of Students and the Scarborough Campus Student Union recently joined. But, as the URSU case shows, support could easily be repealed a year from now.

Wilson says he’s opposed to BDS because it hurts Jewish and Israeli students and is unlikely to advance peace in the Middle East. “Both sides are right and they need to come to a constructive solution,” he says, adding, “and that’s why BDS is so bad, because it doesn’t call for constructive conclusion to the issue, doesn’t call for negotiation or compromise, it just calls for the end of Israel.”

There’s another danger here too, which is that students end up being represented by people who are motivated to run mainly because of their fervent support or hatred for Israel.

I bet most students would prefer that their representatives focus on tuition, residences and public transit. If a Member of Parliament noticed those things, it might actually make a difference.


 

Student leaders shouldn’t focus on Israel

  1. University is the perfect place to foster principled stands against illegal occupation and human rights violations. Congratulations to those students who voted for boycotts and sanctions of Israel.

    • I am an Israeli and Canadian citizen. You call to boycott me and my family and my friends only because we are Israeli (means “Jews” in hypocritical political correct language). Only nation you want to boycott is Israeli nation. It means you are simple racist. Your call for boycott is illegal.

  2. It is entirely possible for student unions to activities related to both local–tuition, residences and public transit–and national or international issues. This isn’t an either-or proposition. Student activism is a time-honoured tradition.

  3. @Jim B:
    University is a place where the vast majority of students are there to learn and earn an academic qualification. Certain students, especially those you deem unprincipled due to their belief in a country whose violations certainly don’t come near most other countries in the region, would believe you have it out for a certain country.
    If you have an issue with occupation or human rights violations, why not protest against Armenia, Azerbaijan, Turkey, Syria, Iran, Iraq, or Saudi Arabia? How about the mass genocides in African countries? Clearly you and others have a bone to pick with one certain country and you want rid of it- that’s the issue here.

  4. Dear Oleg,
    The call is to boycott all companies that profit off Israel’s illegal occupation, that means all Israeli and international companies. BDS is not targeted towards you or your family. We look to boycott companies such as Caterpillar Inc, a US company that regularly demolishes Palestinian homes.

    Every institution is a place to fight for justice and as long as Israel continues to illegally occupy and oppress Palestinians under an illegal apartheid system, nobody will silence us.