Government to appeal court ruling that Metis, other natives are 'Indian' -

Government to appeal court ruling that Metis, other natives are ‘Indian’


OTTAWA – The federal government will appeal a landmark Federal Court ruling which would vastly expand the ranks of people considered Indians under the Constitution.

After more than 13 years of legal wrangling, the court ruled last month that Metis and non-status Indians are indeed “Indians” under a section of the Constitution Act, and therefore fall under federal jurisdiction.

On Wednesday, Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan told the House of Commons that the ramifications of the decision demand a ruling from a higher judicial authority.

“Given that the Federal Court decision raises complex legal issues, it is prudent for Canada to obtain a decision from a higher court,” Duncan said.

“After careful consideration of the decision, Canada has filed an appeal, and it would be inappropriate to comment further as the case is before the courts.”

Among other things, Duncan said, the services provided to Aboriginal Peoples by the federal government have to be affordable.

“The Harper government continues to work in partnership with aboriginal organizations and provincial governments to enhance the economic opportunities for Metis and non-status Indians,” he said.

“Our government must ensure that programs and services to Aboriginal Peoples are fiscally sustainable.”

The case dragged on for years before the ruling last month.

The Congress of Aboriginal Peoples and several Metis and non-status Indians took the federal government to court in 1999, alleging discrimination because they were not considered “Indians” under a section of the Constitution Act.

Filed under:

Government to appeal court ruling that Metis, other natives are ‘Indian’

  1. I feel a notwithstanding moment coming on along with the repeal of the Indian Act.

  2. Well they may have to appeal it, but I doubt it will get them anywhere. More delaying tactics.

    You can’t just change somebody’s ‘race’….although the govt has tried it before.

    For example an ‘Indian’ woman who married a white man ….zap….she was white.

    An Indian man who married a white woman….zap….she was ‘Indian’


    The only questionable ones are Metis….but if we force them to ‘make a choice’, then we can’t blame them for whatever choice they make.