Manitoba Tory leader wishes 'infidel atheists' all the best for the holidays -

Manitoba Tory leader wishes ‘infidel atheists’ all the best for the holidays


WINNIPEG – Manitoba’s Opposition leader has offered his holiday wishes to groups of people including “infidel atheists,” leaving online commentators divided as to whether the phrase was insulting or an awkward attempt at humour.

Brian Pallister gave an impromptu holiday message last week to a citizen journalist armed with a video camera. In the recording, which has thousands of views on YouTube, Pallister offers seasonal greeting to Christians, Jews and others.

“All you infidel atheists out there, I want to wish you the very best also,” the Progressive Conservative leader says on the video.

“I don’t know what you celebrate during the holiday season. I myself celebrate the birth of Christ, but it’s your choice, and I respect your choice. If you wish to celebrate nothing and just get together with friends, that’s good too.”

New Democrat and Liberal party faithful were among the first to spread word of the video on social media. The video was viewed thousands of times over the weekend, spawning a wide range of reaction.

“Merry Christmas to you, from one infidel atheist to a bigoted ‘Christian.’ Judge not lest ye be judged,” read one comment on Twitter.

“I wonder at what point in the video did Brian Pallister start to think he probably should have kept his mouth shut,” read another.

Others characterized the message as a clumsy attempt at humour and pointed out that Pallister’s use of the word is backed by some dictionaries, which define infidel as someone who either does not believe in a particular religion or holds no religious belief.

The head of the Humanists, Atheists and Agnostics of Manitoba said Pallister’s words were equal parts clumsy and offensive, especially given the way the term infidel is used in other parts of the world.

“Being a non-believer or an infidel from the local dominant religion can be almost dangerous to one’s life,” Donna Harris said.

Pallister didn’t directly apologize Monday.

He asked for forgiveness while at the same time defending his use of the word infidel.

“I used a word that means what it means,” Pallister told reporters.

“I’d just ask people in Manitoba, I hope, to forgive me at this time of year if they think I stepped on their toes, but I didn’t. I sincerely just meant to include everyone in my best wishes.”


Manitoba Tory leader wishes ‘infidel atheists’ all the best for the holidays

  1. Christians don’t own Xmas. Jesus isn’t the ‘reason for the season.’

    People have always had mid-winter festivals to lighten the gloom…..Solstice, Saturnalia, Yule….and it always involved trees and a feast and gifts.

    Christians stole the idea, but even the Pope has now admitted it’s all hokum

    Personally I celebrate Sir Isaac Newton’s birthday.

  2. An infidel is someone who doesn’t believe in that religion’s beliefs. So I guess he wasn’t technically incorrect to use that word, and from the way he said it it seemed pretty matter-of-fact and without intended malice.

    But of course one wonder why he used the word “infidel” at all instead of just saying “atheist” or “to those without any particular religious affilliation”. I am an atheist and not offended at all by what he said, but I still wonder why he said it. I’m guessing that it has been drilled into his head so much that he said it without second thought, as if it was perfectly correct and natural to do so.

    • It sounded to me like he was trying to be funny. I’m an ‘infidel atheist’ too, and I didn’t take offence.

      • I don’t think he was trying to be funny. It really sounded like he was making a sincere attempt to be gracious about something he didn’t understand.

        • Maybe he was gonna say ‘godless heathen’, and ‘infidel atheist’ sounded a little more PC.

        • I’ve since discovered he wasn’t trying to be funny. Which makes it much more funny.

    • So if it’s okay for Pallister to say “infidel atheists” then I suppose it will be fine with him if we refer to him as a gullible Christian? It just means he believes.

  3. Since Conservatives have no sense of humour, I think he’s just parroting some sort of fundie Xthian line.