99 stupid things the government did with your money: Part II - Macleans.ca

99 stupid things the government did with your money: Part II

Expensive OJ, sausage research and a report on ‘hi’ in Quebec


For taxpayers concerned with out-of-control government spending, 2012 started on a bright enough note. Last January, the Department of National Defence announced it wanted to buy 20,000 custom-printed stress balls for its staff. Once Defence Minister Peter MacKay caught wind of the plan, he quickly cancelled the contract, calling it an “unnecessary expense of taxpayer money.” Noble words, but it was a brief reprieve. As Maclean’s found once again when researching this project, whether it was Ottawa, the provinces, municipalities or the organizations they oversee, governments couldn’t help themselves when it came to doling out cash. What follows is but a fraction of the foolish, wasteful and blatantly stupid ways governments found to spend taxpayers’ money. To uncover this year’s 99 items we pored over press releases and auditor generals’ reports, sifted through proactive disclosure statements and delved into media databases across the country, ferreting out examples of spending that occurred in 2012 or came to light last year. There will be those who take issue with some items on this list, arguing, for instance, that funding rock concerts boosts the economy. But the reality is that at every level of government, we’re in far worse fiscal shape than we were even a year ago, despite all the talk of cutbacks and austerity. And as this list makes clear, those who control the public purse have yet to really change their ways.

Here are 34 to 66 stupid things on our second annual list of waste that shows spending by all levels of government is still way out of control. Check us out tomorrow to see the last 33 stupid things your government did with your money. (And find 1 to 33 right here.)

34 The Town of Innisfil, Ont., spent four years and $42,000 on outside consultants to design a new logo, even though a local graphic designer offered them a logo she designed for free.

See the world — So long as it’s on the taxpayer’s dime

35 Down under: Claude Benoit, CEO for the Old Port of Montreal, billed taxpayers $10,100 for a 29-day trip she took with a friend to Australia and New Zealand, claiming she was working for part of the trip. In 2012 the federal government asked the auditor general to probe Benoit’s spending after a series of unusual bills, including $7,100 for trips to Sweden and Florida and $38,000 for catered meals to the port offices.

36 Vacant splendour: Alberta spent nearly $114,000 on more than a dozen unoccupied rooms at a five-star hotel in London during the Summer Olympic Games. The province had planned to send 47 people to London to promote Alberta tourism, but scaled back, leaving the rooms at the $850-a-night Le Meridien Piccadilly empty.

37 Working holiday: Councillors in Central Saanich, B.C., didn’t think to check on their colleague Terry Siklenka after giving him a six-month paid leave of absence worth $6,000. If they had, they would have learned he was still hard at work—having taken a job on the side in the Cayman Islands. Only after a media uproar ensued was Siklenka forced to resign.

38 Fumble for fame: B.C.’s Liberal Speaker, Bill Barisoff, his deputy, NDP Claire Trevena, and a clerk billed taxpayers to take their spouses on a junket to Africa, with at least one couple travelling business class at a cost of $7,000 each.

Meanwhile: Alberta’s Conservative government dropped $70,000 on a caucus retreat to the luxurious Fairmont Jasper Park Lodge to brainstorm how to trim the province’s $3-billion deficit.(39); Minister of National Revenue Gail Shea and a staffer spent $2,400 to attend a “Tax Savings Day” event in Toronto to promote a previously announced small-business tax credit (40); Statistics Canada had to cover a $4,000 bill for damage caused to a hotel room by a census enumerator (41); three federal departments spent more than $50,000 sending diplomats and bureaucrats to London to learn how to promote the oil sands (42); the Quebec government spent $200,000 for a bash in Paris to celebrate the province’s 50th anniversary of having a delegation in that city (43).

Reports of wasted spending — are in no way exaggerated

44 Hi and dry: Quebec uncovered yet another threat to the French language in that province—the rising scourge of the word “hi.” Quebec’s language police hired a research firm at a cost of $150,000 to dispatch observers into 400 retailers in downtown Montreal in search of language infractions. The report noted a dangerous increase in the use of “bonjour, hi,” from one per cent of salutations two years ago, to 13 per cent.

45 Public lard-caster: The CBC spent $56,000 to survey its own employees in a sole-sourced contract with Phoenix Strategic Partnership. Surprise, surprise: 80 per cent had a positive impression of the CBC and 70 per cent said the public broadcaster succeeded at “enriching democratic life.”

46 Jet lagged: After dissing reports from the auditor general and Parliamentary Budget Office that warned the price of F-35 fighter jets would be far higher than the $16 billion the Harper government promised, the feds shelled out $645,000 for an outside opinion. After paying KPMG to review the defence department numbers, the government finally accepted the price would be $45 billion.

47 Scooped: When the Guelph Mercury reported complaints from two councillors about city staff in the Ontario town, other councillors voted to have the city’s integrity commissioner look into the matter. Three months and $10,500 later, lawyer Robert Swayze submitted his report, stating any violation was inadvertent, prompting one councillor who voted for the investigation to declare it a “complete waste.”

Meanwhile: A year after the city hired an outside firm to complete an efficiency review of the Toronto Police Service at a cost of $249,965, the police services board put out a tender looking for a consulting firm to look for “delayering” opportunities at a cost of $299,000 (48); a $127,000 report Saskatchewan Health had commissioned from Ornge, Ontario’s troubled air ambulance service, turned out to be ghostwritten by a new M.B.A. grad with no industry experience (49).

Food and entertainment — Living it up on government money

50 Out of juice: Bev Oda proved a glass of juice can end a political career. But the former minister of international co-operation’s taxpayer-funded OJ, which famously cost $16, was only the tastiest of her luxuries. Oda also expensed a $1,000-a-day limo service and a $665-a-night stay at the Savoy hotel in London, only paying the money back after she was exposed.

51 A real hoot: The B.C. ministry of forests plunked down $375 over three separate visits to a Hooters restaurant in Edmonton.

52 Gift wrapped: In an effort to boost morale, the B.C. government has a $1.5-million program called the “recognition cupboard” that encourages employees to select from a wide variety of gifts, all paid for by the government, to give to their co-workers. Among the items employees can give each other on the public dime: Starbucks gift cards, CamelBak water bottles and Mountain Equipment Co-op backpacks.

53 Unhealthy spending: Allaudin Merali, a former CFO with Alberta Health Services, expensed taxpayers for more than $346,000—including $900 spent at a wine store. Merali also expensed $1,750 for repairs to his Mercedes and $2,300 for a new car phone. His punishment? No severance package.

54 Safety Wiener: Agriculture Canada handed $826,000 to Brampton, Ont.’s Cardinal Meat Specialists Ltd. to help the meat-processing company research a sausage that doesn’t burst open when cooked. In a news release, Pierre Lemieux, the parliamentary secretary for agriculture, said a grant to develop a less-explosive sausage was critical to the government’s focus on “jobs, growth, and long-term prosperity.”

Meanwhile: Six months before Alberta’s XL Foods was shut down because of a massive recall of E. coli-tainted meat, the company got a $1.3-million contribution from Ottawa to upgrade its meat-processing facilities (55); The Canada Food Inspection Agency spent $19,900 to ask 1,200 Canadians how to label bottles containing blends of both Canadian and foreign wine—most said “Blended in Canada” (56); Alberta Premier Alison Redford’s sister, Lynn Redford, a health care executive, expensed $3,400 for attending partisan functions (57); Quebec’s state liquor authority, SAQ, paid $24,000 to wine critic James Suckling of Tuscany so he would visit Montreal and review 30 wines, all while denying it gave him any compensation (58).

Weather and Environment — the forecast is for lots of spending

59 Calm down: The City of Waterloo said it plans to spend as much as $90,000 studying whether to erect a wind turbine, despite a 2011 report that showed the city wasn’t windy enough to make the project financially feasible. Regardless of those findings, the federal government gave the city another $63,000 to keep studying its wind turbine project.

60 Walk the talk: In Winnipeg, after a councillor slipped on ice and broke his hip, the city spent $5,000 to help set up a website called Surefoot.org that gives a single general overview of “winter-related walking conditions” for the entire city, from “easy” to “hazardous.” The risk recently: “moderate.”

61 Out of credit: The B.C. Pacific Carbon Trust was set up in 2008 to buy and sell carbon credits with the aim of reducing carbon emissions, but critics say it has mostly served to transfer taxpayer money from schools and hospitals to corporations. Over a year virtually all $14-million worth of credits were purchased by school boards, health authorities and other public agencies. Businesses bought just $54,050 worth. Yet as the Canadian Taxpayers Federation noted, huge companies like Encana, Canfor and Lafarge received an estimated $3 million by reducing carbon emissions and selling credits to the trust.

Meanwhile: The City of Whitehorse and the feds spent $258,000 to figure out a waste-to-energy facility wasn’t economically viable (62); Toronto shelled out $274, 000 to renovate Ted Reeve Community Arena, claiming the retrofits would pay for themselves, when an audit found no energy savings materialized and the arena board repaid just $51,000 of the upfront costs (63).

Nice job — Working for the taxpayer, that is

64 Home alone: Senators who apparently live in the capital full-time are collecting thousands of dollars in living expenses meant to help with the costs of owning a second home in Ottawa. Over the past two years, Mike Duffy, a Conservative senator for P.E.I., has claimed $33,413, even though he spends most of his time at his Ottawa home. Likewise, Liberal Sen. Mac Harb, who has lived in Ottawa since the 1970s, has also received $31,237 while claiming his primary residence is in nearby Pembroke.

65 ‘Cause it hurts: In February, TTC commissioners loyal to Toronto Mayor Rob Ford voted to fire the transit system’s general manager Gary Webster “without cause.” The move triggered two years of severance payments totalling more than $500,000, costing the TTC more than if Webster’s contract had been allowed to expire.

66 Book worm: Barry Holmes, the former CEO of the Greater Victoria Public Library, expensed $132,000 on his corporate credit card over 3½ years, including music downloads and $500 for hemp-based body cream. After leaving his job in Victoria, he took a similar position in Windsor, Ont., where, according to reports, he racked up another $67,000 in credit card charges, including $2,000 for antiques, before quitting.


99 stupid things the government did with your money: Part II

  1. I impressed with that the government use our money like that. so that we also have to Compensation with government. what are the government jobs, you needs.

    • great question. Too bad the truth is when we tell out government what we want, if we did not give them enough money before they got into power they will ignore us once they are the Government and just make moves that will help their friends and those that do lobby them with vast tracks of land… and cash.

  2. Honestly this is the type of feature that I would expect in the National Post.

    Granted some of the items are genuinely wasteful and should be spotlighted.

    Others just fuel the public longing for some unrealistic ideal, a belief that government organizations are some how unique, in that they can never be allowed to make a mistake. Further, if they do realize a mistake, they are are not allowed to acknowledge the mistake, cut the losses and move on.

    I wonder what percentage of the public even understands the concept of a sunk cost?

    • I think articles like these should be written frequently to remind the government to spend our money wisely. Inefficient ouse of tax money is one of the biggest issues in government. If the Canadian Government is able to spend money on low priorities like the ones shown in this article, then they are clearly taking too much money from its citizens.

      • Agreed at 100.000%. The reason our pockets are empty while the cupboards are full is because of the Harper Government of Canafta picking and choosing winners and losers from those that come before them. And politicians these days come to the plate with a full agenda that we know nothing about, just snippets of half truths and whispers in the wind of potential future developments for those that pony up (and this journo is looking at 5th and George in Prince George BC CANADA. All this wrapped in a social philosophy that Government should not be in business yet government should also not tax businesses. So if I take Detroit Michigan as an example of a place where the tax base was deliberately and with malice aforethought continually weakened to the point of financial implosion, the real life economic fallout was a situation where businesses that were long successful (and the business model was to extract the wealth from a geographical region to another perhaps even offshore), were then allowed to pick up roots and bugger off to the next taker of their entice, capture, rape, and pillage social capital ideology = Hello NeoMichigan… maybe even here hmmmm… Years ago I extended the concept of Concentric Zone Theory to include Social Zone Theory and the Community Based Policing Model. The conclusions drawn are solid and are eloquently and concisely stated thus:
        Currently, at a 100.000% probability factor, #pmharpermustresign, fullstop.

    • Do you work for government?

  3. Seriously, Macleans, calling Innisfil out for #34 is ridiculous. That was $42,000 for over 4 years of design work and consultation, which means it was $10,000 per year for a professional agency’s work for coming up with branding and strategy for an entire town, which is shockingly low by most agency standards. You want that refunded to taxpayers? Everyone can enjoy their 0.05 cents per year for four years that they’d get back. Did you even see the free logo? It looks like it would be free. Sometimes you get what you pay for, especially with design. I’m sure the designers that work for you would be happy to know that you’d fire them all if someone came along and decided to do their job, 2000 times worse, for free.

    • That’s ridiculous, my design firm would have done it for $1,000.00. There are better things to be spending money on than brand.

  4. To suggest it was a waste of money to provide bullet-proof vests to Ontario’s Park Warden diminishes the credibility of Macleans Magazine; Park Wardens have the same authority as a member of the OPP in a provincial park including the enforcement of both criminal and provincial laws, and do so with nothing but a baton. As a taxpayer, I’d rather pay the almost $300 Thousand to equip Park Wardens with body armour then to see a Park Warden die on the job and see his/her family in pain.

    Macleans Magazine’s hazardous argument suggesting that it was a waste of money to buy the vests as no Park Warden has ever been shot is akin to saying it is a waste of money to provide construction workers with hardhats if no one has yet died on the site by a falling object; a typical Canadian “wait and see” approach that is the reason why Canada has one the highest industrial accident fatality rates in the developed world.

  5. I dont agree with what the government is doing at all!!

  6. Income tax is theft of your labor.