‘Their pipeline is now a pipe dream’

B.C. First Nation along pipeline route officially rejects Northern Gateway plan


FORT ST. JAMES, B.C. – A group of First Nations with territory covering a quarter of the route for the proposed Northern Gateway oil pipeline met with federal representatives Friday to officially reject the project.

Officials with the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency, the National Energy Board and the Department of Fisheries and Oceans met with the four clans of the Yinka Dene in Fort St. James, and listened as dozens of elders, hereditary and elected chiefs said “No.”

“We do not, we will not, allow this pipeline,” Peter Erickson, a hereditary chief of the Nak’azdli First Nation, told the six federal bureaucrats.

“We’re going to send the message today to the federal government and to the company itself: their pipeline is dead. Under no circumstances will that proposal be allowed.

“Their pipeline is now a pipe dream.”

Karen Ogan, chief of the Wet’suwet’en, thanked the Crown representatives for listening. During the often emotional meeting, Ogan touched on the country’s checkered past with First Nations and its role in the dispute.

“Some people may come from an anger perspective because we’ve been bulldozed, we’ve been run over all through history, through colonization and today we want our voice to be heard,” Ogan told the six bureaucrats during the day-long meeting.

The bands said the project is now banned from Yinka Dene territories, under their traditional laws.

Members young and old of the Nadleh Whut’en, Nak’azdli, Saik’uz, Takla Lake, Tl’azt’en and Wet’suwet’en communities were unanimous. They said the decision by the four clans marks the end of negotiations.

The pipeline project faces a major hurdle in getting First Nations on board but behind the scenes negotiations have continued talking with many groups. The company has also signed several benefits agreements with First Nations, though few of them admit publicly to the deals.

The Yinka Dene has spearheaded a petition against the pipeline that has been signed by 160 First Nations groups in B.C. — most not located near the proposed pipeline route.

Last month, the company announced that it asked former conservative minister of Indian affairs Jim Prentice to try and mediate deals with First Nations opposed to the project.

The $6-billion, nearly 1,200-kilometre pipeline would deliver 525,000 barrels of petroleum a day from Edmonton to a tanker terminal in Kitimat, on the north coast.

The federal government claims Canada is losing billions of dollars a year because western Canadian oil is not reaching markets overseas. Enbridge (TSX:ENB) has said Northern Gateway is expected to grow the Canadian GDP by more than $300 billion over 30 years.

But the pipeline became a lightning rod in the debate over global climate change and raised alarm over the possibility of an oil spill on land or off the coast of B.C.

A federal review panel recommended approval of the pipeline with 209 conditions. A final decision is expected from the federal government in June but several B.C. First Nations have filed appeals with the Federal Court seeking to overturn the panel recommendation.

The challenge for the company does not lie solely in First Nations communities. Several municipalities in northern B.C. have voted to oppose the project, Terrace, Prince Rupert and Smithers.

Council in Kitimat, the would-be terminus of the pipeline, is about to end its neutral stance on the project. Residents vote in a plebiscite Saturday that will decide the district’s position.


‘Their pipeline is now a pipe dream’

  1. Another thing Harper never saw coming….

    • What have you ever seen coming?

  2. Enbridge will find another route, and whichever groups have opposed will merely lose out. There’s too much money involved here, and not enough science… of ANY kind… I’m surprised at how many opponents to this pipeline have no involvement whatsoever, and a number of these opponents are not even Canadian… The Natives may call this pipeline dead; it will be rerouted.

    • It will be stopped one way or the other. Reality bites.

      • You know all about biting it.

        The pipeline will be built to the coast.
        Those who oppose it will lose out on the benefits, which is fitting.

  3. Easy solution. Find a politician with a spine and say it as it is. No pipeline, no jobs, no taxes then no free welfare.

    As its all about getting other peoples money for nothing, extortion based on race because this country can’t say we are all EQUAL and participating. As one races presence is discrimination to others. Time these people did something for society other than screw it up wanting more “free” money and idle time.

    • More racism isn’t going to get your oil to market Dave. Haven’t you figured that out yet?

  4. There is another route, by rail to the Alaskan pipeline and on to Valdez. NWT, the Yukon and Alaska are all for it.

    Too bad BC will lose out on money, jobs and possibly an 18 billion dollar refinery.

    But then again the “watermelons” don’t really care where their welfare cheques come from until they’re cut off.