Chief blames ‘third world’ conditions for deadly house fire

Pikangikum fire killed six adults and three children

An abandoned house is shown on the Pikangikum First Nation, Friday, January 5, 2007. Police say there's been a fatal house fire on the Pikangikum First Nation in northwestern Ontario and several people have died. THE CANADIAN PRESS/John Woods

An abandoned house is shown on the Pikangikum First Nation (File photo, CP).

A First Nations chief says the deaths of nine people in a house fire on a remote northern Ontario reserve should spur the federal government to improve what he says are third-world conditions on dozens of reserves across the country.

“We can’t let these people die in vain,” said regional Chief Isadore Day with the Chiefs of Ontario.

“There should be a direct and immediate response to this situation. This is typical across all First Nations that are living in third-world conditions.”

A blaze erupted in a family home late Tuesday night on Pikangikum First Nation, killing six adults and three children.

A fundraising page established by a community member identified the dead as Gilbert and Annette Strang, their daughter Faith, Faith’s husband, Dietrich Peters, and the younger couple’s three children — Ireland, 4, Aubree, 2, and Amber, who was just eight months old.

The Strang’s son Gilbert and his wife, Sylvia Peters, also died in the blaze, it said.

Previous inquests into similar tragedies have highlighted the challenges facing remote northern reserves such as Pikangikum.

Homes are dilapidated, not built to comply with any modern code, and often don’t have running water, let alone a smoke detector. There are often several generations of families sharing a tiny bungalow, heightening the potential toll fires can take when they break out.

“Most homes are simply a death trap,” Day said.

When fires erupt, they spread quickly and communities are often woefully unprepared to respond. Many don’t have fire trucks and rely on water trucks which provide the same kind of pressure as a garden hose. If a community is lucky enough to have a fire truck, both inquests and internal government reports have found, there are often not enough trained volunteers to operate it properly.

In Pikangikum, Day said more than 90 per cent of homes don’t have running water.

“Is there going to be a fire hydrant outside? No, there isn’t.”

An internal federal government report examining insurance coverage for First Nations communities, obtained by The Canadian Press through Access to Information legislation, found almost half the First Nations across Canada have “little to no fire protection” and rely too heavily on poorly trained volunteer firefighters who can’t do the job.

The 2011 report found fire incidence rates for First Nations are 2.4 times higher than for the rest of Canada. First Nations residents are also 10 times more likely to die in a house fire than someone living off reserve.

Last year, a Manitoba judge examining the deaths of three children and a grandfather in house fires on remote northern reserves recommended all First Nations communities have 911 service. Judge Tracey Lord also recommended better co-ordinated firefighting training for First Nations communities and greater priority of fire safety inspections.

Federal NDP critic Charlie Angus, who represents a vast northern Ontario riding, said inquests into similar fires in Ontario have also laid out a road map to prevent future tragedies.

“It needs political will,” he said. “What we need out of this tragedy is a message that the days of leaving the safety of children to chance are over.”

Filed under:

Chief blames ‘third world’ conditions for deadly house fire

  1. A Macleans author suggests leaving reservations to escape poverty – is widely pilloried.

    Previous government required opening books to show where bands are spending money – is widely pilloried.

    95% of the residents in this community don’t have running water.

    Can we have a mature discussion about how to address some fundamental problems, or are both sides going to play the blame/shame game about things that happened decades ago?

    • Well see that’s the thing and this article proves the point.

      You cannot have a mature discussion with Indigenous groups or activists because the blame is ALWAYS, unequivocally, on others. When was the last time you heard anything about personal responsibility regarding any issue from the Indigenous industry? That’s right, never. To them, personal responsibility does not exist as seen in issue after issue.

      The fact that personal responsibility never gets any playtime is the single largest driver of distrust Canadians have towards Indigenous politics.

      The recent deaths of these people is a tragedy plain and simple. My sympathy to the families and community. It must be devastating.

      Now the elephant in the room. Did you know in Canada it is against the law to not have working smoke detectors? In 2016, it is reprehensible that someone would live in a dwelling without these miracles of technology. For a few dollars a family can be protected by the ravages of combustion that have killed thousands upon thousands in the past.

      That FN communities have failed to educate and provide if needed, smoke detectors to their people is unforgivable.

      The blame for high rates of deaths in house fires in FN communities lay at the feet of FN leaders and no one else. There are no excuses here, the blame is theirs and theirs alone. Stand up and take responsibility like real leaders instead of acting like cowards and placing blame on Canada.

  2. In ‘third world’ conditions the chief doesn’t collect 100k of tax-free money. Fiddler should step down if not EVERY house in his community has a working $20 smoke detector. This inaction and pointing at others (the funding trough) makes me angry for the senseless loss of that precious life.

Sign in to comment.