NDP MPs told to pay back $1.17 million

NDP found to have improperly used parliamentary resources for partisan purposes

Government whip and chair of the Board of Internal Economy John Duncan. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

Government whip and chair of the Board of Internal Economy John Duncan. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

OTTAWA – New Democrat MPs are on the hook for $1.17 million after a secretive House of Commons committee found them guilty Wednesday of improperly spending parliamentary resources for partisan purposes.

The MPs in question owe $36,000 to the House, while the remaining $1.13 million is owed to Canada Post, Conservative MP John Duncan told a news conference.

“The bylaws are clear: members of Parliament are accountable for any use of House resources,” said Duncan, a spokesman for the board of internal economy — the multi-party committee that oversees Commons spending.

“As such, the House administration has been directed to seek reimbursement directly from the members.”

The multi-party board has been investigating almost 2 million partisan flyers sent by the NDP MPs to households in 26 different ridings, including four that were in the midst of byelections late last year.

It will be up to the individual MPs to work directly with Canada Post to arrange repayment, Duncan said.

“The board cannot compel members to repay these costs; however, it is incumbent on these members to work with Canada Post to repay the $1.13 million.”

The board has also been investigating the use of Commons budgets to pay the salaries of NDP staffers in satellite party offices in Montreal, Quebec City and Toronto, but Duncan said a decision on that issue has not been made.

Within minutes of Duncan’s news conference, NDP House leader Peter Julian was hosting one of his own — with party lawyer Julius Grey in tow.

“We believe that we have followed the member’s bylaws and the Canada Post Act, and we will now have to fight this process — by a partisan secretive body that is dominated by Conservatives — outside of Parliament,” Julian said.

The board has acted as judge, jury and executioner, passing judgment without holding a hearing, calling witnesses or providing an opportunity to review the evidence, he added.

“None of this will hold up in a court of law.”

A simple reading of the act shows clearly that “there couldn’t possibly be an illegality,” added Grey.

“It is obvious that we have a direct assault on the basic principles of the Constitution. In these circumstances, there is no choice but to proceed to judicial review…. It’s an invention, it’s a complete miscarriage of justice.”

NDP Leader Tom Mulcair has accused Conservatives and Liberals of turning the board into a “kangaroo court” where only the NDP has been targeted for practices indulged in by all parties.

Tom Mulcair said earlier Wednesday that a guilty verdict and repayment order would not come as a surprise.

“We’re taking it for granted, frankly, that they’re going to come out against us,” he said.

He complained that the board offered the party “no process, no right to be heard, no right to educe evidence, no right to see that the rules are applied equally to everyone.”

Duncan has said the Commons could garnishee the budgets of New Democrat MPs if they don’t voluntarily repay.

As he has done repeatedly since controversy erupted over NDP mailings and satellite offices several months ago, Mulcair insisted New Democrats have followed all the rules.

The Speaker of the Commons, Andrew Scheer, and House of Commons administration have contradicted NDP claims that they approved the mailings or the use of MPs’ office budgets to pay staffers in satellite offices.

Filed under:

NDP MPs told to pay back $1.17 million

  1. I can’t believe the NDP and MP Peter Julian are using the “Wallin/Duffy” defense on this issue. This is the Harper way of doing things, fighting back loudly and petulantly. The NDP should pay the money back and make the months of future headlines go away.

    • Combined with the non-Ottawa based parliamentary offices (including those planned for Sask.), I am dumbfounded by the NDP’s willingness to sully their brand.

      In this particular case, the material sent was no more egregious than that sent by the Liberals or Conservatives (indeed arguably less so). Still, what is partisan is a fuzzy notion and very tough to regulate. There was however a very clear regulation to not put the party web site on the pamphlet, and the NDP did. I suspect it was inadvertent (who needs a URL these days), but still it was one crystal clear regulation sitting among a fog of other rules. They should pay up quickly and quietly and put this to bed.

  2. Well, if I’d known that the many flyers I received in the mail from CPC MPs in my NDP-held constituency, telling me of the glories of the Harper government, were illegal, as well as inane, I certainly would have drawn it to the attention of the authorities. I’m sure they know better now, and will turn themselves in to the committee in question.

  3. The CPC mail outs are viciously partisan and not informative or usefull.

    NDP don’t pay; make them drag you away in handcuffs with the cameras rolling.

  4. Absolute, pure hypocrisy on the part of the CPC. I regularly get mailings from my MP, Bal Gosal. Every one is 100% pure partisan BS. If the NDP have to pay then I expect to see Bal Gosal do the same.


  5. You notice how that “secret-closed-door” judgement call against NDP was timed perfectly, just before theses Ontario Elections ? … mmm?
    Those Tories really are sleeze bags.

Sign in to comment.