Tory MP says niqab comments went too far but stands by his point of view

MP Larry Miller apologized for his suggestion that new citizens who disagreed with the niqab ban should ‘stay the hell where you came from’

Larry Miller, Conservative MP for Bruce Grey- Owen Sound. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

Larry Miller, Conservative MP for Bruce Grey- Owen Sound. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

OTTAWA – Ontario Tory MP Larry Miller has been forced to apologize after suggesting that those who wish to wear a niqab while swearing the oath of citizenship ought to “stay the hell where you came from.”

Opposition politicians are saying his remarks are proof of a new low in Canadian politics brought about by a prime minister bent on dividing the country.

Miller made the comments on a call-in show on Owen Sound radio station CFOS on Monday, saying he was baffled as to why the Federal Court overturned a ban on the wearing of niqabs during citizenship ceremonies.

“If you’re not willing to show your face in the ceremony that you’re joining the best country in the world, then frankly if you don’t like that or don’t want to do that, stay the hell where you came from,” Miller said.

“And I think most Canadians feel the same, that’s maybe saying it a little harshly but it’s the way… I’m so sick and tired of people wanting to come here because they know it’s a good country and then they want to change things before they even really officially become a Canadian.”

The federal government is appealing the court decision and the prime minister has said he believes it goes against Canadian values to wear a full-face covering during a citizenship ceremony.

But on Tuesday, his office said Miller went too far.

A spokesman said Miller’s remarks were inappropriate and went beyond “our clear position.”

“What the prime minister has stated is that we believe it is offensive that someone would cover their face at the very moment they want to join the Canadian family,” Carl Vallee said in an e-mail.


Miller echoed that theme in his apology Tuesday.

“I stand by my view that anyone being sworn in as a new citizen of our country must uncover their face. However, I apologize for and retract my comments that went beyond this,” he said in a statement.

Justin Trudeau said the comments prove his point that Harper is stoking fear and prejudice against Muslims.

“This is a prime minister who encourages and condones the politics of division and fear and that is very dangerous in Canada, in a pluralistic, strong, free society like ours,” Trudeau said in a telephone interview.

New Democrat MP Jinny Sims said Harper is leading his caucus down a dangerous path:

“Who else are we going to say keep the hell away from here? Is it going to be, is it going to be based on the colour of your skin? What you wear? Where do you draw those lines? Who is really being told to stay away from here?”

Filed under:

Tory MP says niqab comments went too far but stands by his point of view

  1. It’s like they are trying to prove Trudeau’s point. Or rather, that they cannot help themselves because he is right.

  2. I have recently made a petition to ban the niqab in Canada. If you would like to see it go to my web site at evangelistsofcanada.ca I have an MP that will take it to Ottawa for me and we have had over 200 signatures in the last 4 weeks with limited circulation.

    • I see from your website you are proud to have been convicted of a hate crime. How nice for you!

  3. Trudeau is still wet behind the ears. It will be some time before he ever becomes the politician his father was. If a person is not a Canadian then they should not force their beliefs on those of us who are.

    • Who is forcing their beliefs on whom? She isn’t trying to make you wear a niqab; on the other hand, Harper is telling her she can’t. Looks to me like you have things back-asswards.

      If the government is telling her a symbol of her faith is unacceptable, then they – and collectively, as they are our representatives, we – are saying s. 2 of the Charter does not apply equally to everyone. You’ll be OK with that when it’s your turn to have your rights stripped away?

Sign in to comment.