Pakistan cozies up to China -

Pakistan cozies up to China

As relations with the U.S. erode, Islamabad finds a friend in Beijing

Cozying up to China

China Daily/REUTERS

Pakistan’s ambassador to China used a recent celebration of his country’s Republic Day to give a rhetoric-filled talk about Beijing-Islamabad relations. If March 23, 1940, was the day the Muslim League decided to establish Pakistan, then the anniversary would be a time to declare that relations with China will define the way forward. “We shall take our bilateral relations to new heights,” Masood Khan proclaimed. “China and Pakistan are the best friends in the world.” The warm words echoed those of Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao, who said during a December visit to Pakistan that the neighbours would “remain brothers forever.” Such events, of course, can be mere exercises in diplomacy. But in Wen’s case, the sentiment seemed sincere; it was backed by $35 billion in economic deals, and he rolled out a proposal to help Pakistan’s rebuilding after last summer’s flooding, even suggesting that 2011 be the “Year of China-Pakistan Friendship.”

If China appears to be paying special attention to Pakistan lately, it may be because it senses a real opportunity. Pakistan’s relations with its most powerful ally, the United States, have been souring for some time, possibly leaving Islamabad open to other overtures. Most recently, in March, Pakistanis protested and burned American flags over the release of Raymond Davis, a CIA contractor who confessed to killing two men in Lahore. Though he was freed after families of the victims were paid “blood money,” the case further bruised the Washington-Islamabad alliance. Even in the art galleries of Karachi, exhibitions featured critiques of the “fair-weather” friendship. As Michael Krepon wrote on the Arms Control Wonk blog, “U.S.-Pakistan ties are the worst I can recall in almost two decades of visits, and are likely to deteriorate further.”

Fraying ties with one global superpower, however, do not fully explain the vigour of the China friendship. Pakistan has been moving into China’s sphere of influence for decades, and the countries routinely refer to each other as “all-weather” partners. This year will mark the 60th anniversary of diplomatic relations. “Even when I was there in 1981, ’82, I could see Chinese military factories going up,” says Stephen Cohen, a Pakistan expert at the Brookings Institution. Now, Pakistan represents a major market for China’s nuclear and military technology. According to SIPRI, a Swedish think tank, over 40 per cent of Chinese arms exports go to Pakistan—the largest share of any country China sells to. New U.S. intelligence assessments concluded that Pakistan has been steadily growing its nuclear arsenal since President Barack Obama came to power in 2008, and it is poised to overtake Britain as the world’s fifth-largest nuclear weapons power. This is largely thanks to the People’s Republic. Cohen says, “No one did not believe that the Chinese role was not critical and remains important.”

China also recently announced that it would forge ahead with plans to build two more nuclear power reactors in Pakistan—despite the crisis in Japan and global concerns over atomic safety. So it helps, of course, that the China-Pakistan union is a relationship devoid of criticism. Like most countries that benefit from China’s deep pockets, says South Asia analyst Teresita C. Schaffer, “the Pakistanis don’t do things we do that embarrass our friends, like hassle visitors about human rights.”

Meanwhile, relations between the two Asian nations balance ever-warmer ties between the U.S. and Pakistan’s arch-rival, India. Since the Sino-Indian war in 1962, Pakistan has viewed China as a regional counterweight to rising India, whose presence has been a source of security concerns following partition in 1947, and three subsequent major wars. “India is bigger and more successful economically,” says Schaffer. “[Pakistan] has always sought to make friends with powerful outsiders, in order to compensate for India’s larger size.”

But the syrupy rhetoric regarding Pakistan’s friendship with China can be deceiving. “China did not help Pakistan in the 1965 war, and did nothing in the 1971 war,” says Christine Fair, assistant professor at Georgetown University. “It took the side of India in the 1999 Kargil war.” China’s trade with India outstrips trade with Pakistan. Fair adds, “Yes, China has been a consistent military provider, but the logic there is to keep Pakistan in the position to distract India.” Other analysts point out that investing in Pakistan’s ports and infrastructure gives China an alternative route for energy sources. Fair concludes, “The Pakistan-China marriage looks like a love marriage but it’s also a marriage of convenience. The only difference is, China doesn’t complain about Pakistan, but we do.”

Still, at a time when it seems everything is going wrong for Islamabad­—rising food prices and inflation paired with a weak currency, a middle class that has virtually disappeared, and a society that is increasingly fragmented—it feels it has a friend in Beijing. Though, as Cohen points out, “Pakistan may not be such a great prize for China. Between ethnic violence and religious quarrels, it’s coming apart at the seams.”


Pakistan cozies up to China

  1. Why don't we ask Moammar what cozying up to the Chinese gets ya? I guess it can't be much worse for Pakistan than it already is.

  2. “No one did not believe that the Chinese role was not critical and remains important.”

    Worst sentence ever.

  3. The Chinese are proving to be so much better at this realpolitik stuff than we are.

  4. It seems Pakistan has had enough of America and the West. They think that their country played a key role in defeating the Soviet Union in Afghanistan, and therefore making America the NO1 super power in the World. But susequently, America and the rest of the World abondoned them and left them with enormous problems of destabalised Afghanistan and millions of refugees on its soil. So, Pakistani leadership and people belive that they have been manipulated and taken for granted, and that, enough is enough.

    • Pakistan shot itself in the foot a looooong time ago with their unwillingness to get with the program. The fact that they blame everyone else for their problems is nothing new. They are 'muslim' therefore perfect. Perfect morons, more likely. They are in the process on destroying themselves and there is nothing us infidels can say to them that will change the fact. China is going to come in and show them just what "lock-down" management really is.

  5. Pakistan helped the US in defeating the Soviet Union in Afghanistan, but isn't it true that the US helped Pakistan in fending off the Soviet Union? Pakistan would have been part of the soviet union if the US didn't intervene. It was a mutual interest, why do people from Pakistan always say "we helped America", you helped yourself by helping America.

  6. Seeing what happened in Japan, China has been planning to halt their planned nuclear projects. Don't tell me, those are second hand reactors being sold to Pakistan? Considering Pakistan's work ethics, corruption, greed, blinding ambition, none existent quality control, and cutting corners reputation, China might be helping Pakistan's demise instead. Smart move by China, sell unwanted equipment at a price and gained a reputation as benevolent godfather for Pakistan. Hope they and this transaction won't poison each other's backside.

  7. We'll see how long this "friendship" lasts when China's Muslim minority starts getting deadly serious about throwing off the Chinese yoke.

  8. What makes you think Pakistan cares about China's Muslims ?

  9. for sale high quality n i k e shoes and other sporting goods.

    sunglasses hut