The myth of Justin Trudeau’s youthful government - Macleans.ca
  7

The myth of Justin Trudeau’s youthful government

Justin Trudeau’s government is lauded as a crew of bright whippersnappers learning the ropes—the reality is much more grey.


 
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his cabinet arrive at Parliament Hill for their first Cabinet meeting after being sworn-in earlier in the day. November 4, 2015. (Prime Minister's Office)

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his cabinet arrive at Parliament Hill for their first Cabinet meeting after being sworn-in earlier in the day on November 4, 2015. (Prime Minister’s Office)

There’s a wave of youngsters taking office worldwide—or so headlines will have you believe. Certainly, more political leaders are skewing young these days. Canada’s three major parties are now each led by late Gen-Xers (Justin Trudeau, 45, Andrew Scheer, 38, and Jagmeet Singh, 38). Likewise, France and New Zealand recently elected their first leaders to not know the horror of writing a college paper without the internet, and the incoming chancellor of Austria, 31-year-old Sebastian Kurz, hardly knows a time before cellphones.

In 2015, a then-43-year-old Justin Trudeau became one of Canada’s youngest prime ministers, second only to Joe Clark, who took office the day before his 40th birthday. Trudeau’s cabinet, by extension, is often characterized as youthful—a cohort of green, starry-eyed keeners finding their way at the outset of their political careers.

In reality, Trudeau’s government is not particularly young.

The average age of his cabinet is 50.7—a whisker younger than Brian Mulroney’s cabinets (1984-93), which averaged 50.9 years old, and nearly four years older than John Turner’s brief cabinet (1984), which evidently took to heart the motto “live fast, die young.” Pierre Elliott Trudeau’s cabinets (1968-79, 1980-84) were younger than his son’s, as were the cabinets of Joe Clark (1979-80) and Kim Campbell (1993).

Of course, that’s just looking at the average age in cabinet over the course of each government’s time in office. Perhaps more interesting is the proportion of youthful ministers in each cabinet. Overall as a cabinet, the current Liberals are on the younger side: five of them—about 15 per cent—are, or have been at some point during their term, under 40. But Trudeau Sr.’s first cabinet was younger still, with nine members—just under 16.5 per cent—under 40. Both Harper’s and Turner’s cabinets were close behind, with about 14 per cent under 40 at some point.

It’s worth noting that cabinets tend to be younger in their early years in office than at the end, simply because most members stick around and age with the government. That may be one reason why the short-lived governments of Clark, Turner and Campbell skewed so young. Likewise, it might seem reasonable to assume Trudeau’s government would be young now but that it won’t be by the end of its first or perhaps second term.

But just two years in, not only is the government not young—it’s old. Trudeau’s cabinet has more senior citizens than any other in recent history—and by a substantial margin. So far, it has had seven cabinet members over 64. That’s more than 21 per cent of its total members, and about six per cent more old folks than the next oldest government, Stephen Harper’s.


Comparing the Canadian PMs

Justin Trudeau

Justin Trudeau Liberal • 2015–present

Cabinet’s average age: 50.7

Percentage over 64: 21.2%


Stephen Harper

Stephen Harper Conservative • 2006–2015

Cabinet’s average age: 52.6

Percentage over 64: 15.4%


Paul Martin

Paul Martin Liberal • 2003–2006

Cabinet’s average age: 54.4

Percentage over 64: 12.5%


Jean Chrétien

Jean Chrétien Liberal • 1993–2003

Cabinet’s average age: 52.4

Percentage over 64: 11.1%


Kim Campbell

Kim Campbell Progressive Conservative • 1993

Cabinet’s average age: 50.1

Percentage over 64: 0%


Brian Mulroney

Brian Mulroney Progressive Conservative • 1984–1993

Cabinet’s average age: 50.9

Percentage over 64: 4.3%


John Turner

John Turner Liberal • 1984

Cabinet’s average age: 47

Percentage over 64: 0%


Pierre Elliott Trudeau

Pierre Elliott Trudeau Liberal • 1980–1984

Cabinet’s average age: 49.3

Percentage over 64: 0%


Joe Clark

Joe Clark Progressive Conservative • 1979–1980

Cabinet’s average age: 48.2

Percentage over 64: 0%


Pierre Elliott Trudeau

Pierre Elliott Trudeau Liberal • 1968–1979

Cabinet’s average age: 49.7

Percentage over 64: 5.5%


Correction: due to an editing error, an earlier version of this infographic misstated the political party of Kim Campbell, Joe Clark and Brian Mulroney.


 

The myth of Justin Trudeau’s youthful government

  1. Isn’t that more a commentary on the number or Pols who are being elected into ‘careers’ spanning multiple decades. Ours is a ‘tosser’ and he’s in his 5th term. We, the electorate, are content with solid performance on Ottawa visits, hidden mistakes and not too much excitement.

  2. Classic lazy journalism. Create a myth that no one was even talking about and then attack it.

  3. Now lets compare the IQ level of each government. First we have to separate the creationists from the people who live in the real reality, because if you need ideology to steer your way through life, than your IQ is about the level of a green pea.

    • Trudeau has a young front bench with more bright young and dynamic women in the forefront. Trudeau is first to change the face of cabinet in the HOCs, with a 50/50 gender balance, now that is progress over age.

  4. This is really interesting. Why weren’t there any over-64s pre-Mulroney days? Politicians dying young from a chainsmoking boozer lifestyle? Post-1993 it seems there are lot more vigorous people who lived healthily and turned to politics as a second career, with their PMs valuing their experience.

  5. Candian publication. 32 comments on a Donald Trump article, 5 comments on an article concerning the government of Canada. Reminds me of the Rob Ford days when “connected” young voters were so engaged in politics, following a sensationalist story that had no bearing on their lives. Everyone was too busy following the Ford circus to realize that the Wynne government was destroying Ontario. Now it is happening with Donald Trump and the Trudeau government. Sad state of affairs. Canadians need to wake up and realize they have their own cancerous government to deal with, but they seem too content absconding on their own democratic responsibility in favour of following a circus. We deserve all the corruption, mismanagement and larceny we are getting from this governemnt.

  6. Actually, it was the media that blabbed on and on about Trudeau’s age and that of his cabinet and they did so as a way of attacking him and his government.

    Now you’re saying that the media was full of $h!t but still you use it as a way to attack him.

Sign in to comment.