One photo, less than 1,000 words: What is a Canadian? -

One photo, less than 1,000 words: What is a Canadian?

A viral photo suggests Canada is a welcoming place for those seeking asylum. But how welcoming are we?

Family members from Somalia are helped into Canada by RCMP officers along the U.S.-Canada border near Hemmingford, Que., on Friday, February 17, 2017. A number of refugee claimants are braving the elements to illicitly enter Canada. (Paul Chiasson/CP)

Family members from Somalia are helped into Canada by RCMP officers along the U.S.-Canada border near Hemmingford, Que., on Friday, February 17, 2017. A number of refugee claimants are braving the elements to illicitly enter Canada. (Paul Chiasson/CP)

The story goes like this: As a taxi full of people approached the Canadian border near Hemmingford, Quebec on Friday from the U.S. side, American border guards moved to intercept it. That’s when the doors of the car opened and eight people – four adults and four children – got out and ran to Canada.

Waiting on the other side of the border were some RCMP officers and a photographer for the Canadian Press. As the group scrambled through the snow to the Canadian side of the border, one officer picked up one of the children. Paul Chiasson snapped a photo.

That’s one story of the photograph, anyway. But there is another.

About two and a half hours down the road, in Ottawa, the talk in the prior days was all about who belongs and who might not, and about how we ought to treat each other.

RELATED: The new underground railroad to Canada

A relatively innocuous motion recommending a parliamentary committee be struck to study Islamophobia – that is, acts of a divisive nature – had itself become incredibly divisive, as accusations floated around about limitations being placed on various freedoms guaranteed by our Charter, or about whose fault it was that division exists in the first place.

And these two events would not be related necessarily were it not for the fact that a few weeks ago Donald Trump had singled out seven predominantly Muslim nations from which the United States might yet still, pending a rewrite of the law, ban arrivals. Included in that list of countries is Sudan, where the eight people who arrived in Hemmingford Friday told a Reuters reporter they are originally from.

Since the Trump campaign began only a few short months after our own election in late 2015 that was fought, in part, over our willingness to give into fear of the Other, Canadians have looked south and wondered a lot about how different we really are from our neighbours. Essays and think pieces have been written to support both sides of this conundrum: we are very, very different, say some; we are not that different at all, say others.

This existential quandary is hardly new. We have long been torn about what kind of a country we live in, and therefore by extension, what kind of people we are.

In 1972, June Callwood, the then-head of the Canadian Civil Liberties Association wrote in this magazine that, since the War Measures Act had been introduced two years prior in Quebec, she had been “trying to adjust myself to the realization that what I believed all my life about Canada – a land somehow more noble than any other, more tolerant, brave, and even true, whatever true means – never existed at all except in my head, where its sole function was to enlarge my vision of me, the typical Canadian, noble, tolerant, brave and, especially, true.”

Disabused of that vision, and looking back through history on the abuses wrought within these borders, Callwood decided instead that, “Canadians are a nasty lot.”

Indeed, Canada’s current welcome mat is not as clean as we might think. In recent years, we have learned more about how Canada often treats undocumented migrants once they have been detained. Immigration detainees are often held in correctional facilities with criminals, for instance. The deaths of three immigration detainees in the spring of 2016 prompted the public safety minister to order a review of the system.

More pressingly, in the days since Trump’s travel ban was ham-fistedly, and briefly, implemented, there have been calls for Canada to end its participation in the Safe Third Country agreement, under which Canada returns asylum seekers who enter at ports of entry from the United States back to the United States. This is why folks are walking across the border at random spots, away from formal crossing points. At the very least, suspending the agreement would mean those seeking asylum in Canada might not have to risk frozen limbs or death to attain it.

RELATED: Canada must respond to an unsafe America

But despite these persistent issues that must be addressed, in general we continue to tell ourselves that, well, at least we are not the United States. Otherwise, why would people like the eight who ran through the snow Friday want to come here?

For as long as the two nations have existed in some form beside one another, Canadians have considered the United States in this comparative manner – as a measuring stick against which we gauge ourselves. The U.S. is an elephant to our mouse; a Goliath to our David, and so forth. We note those differences and think they are what must define us. But it seems our perception is wrong. Rather than a sibling or even a neighbour, the U.S. is our mirror. When we have looked there, we have only ever been seeing ourselves reflected.

So, then: What is a Canadian? How do you know when you see one? How do you know when you’re holding one?

As Chiasson’s photograph went viral online Friday afternoon, there were some who fretted about larger implications if these eight people, should their claims for refugee status stand, be allowed into the country. That is, could Canada become too welcoming? But mostly people just looked at the face of the RCMP officer with the young child in his hands, perhaps interpreting his expression simply as that of a man relieved to complete a job he’d been sent to do: ensuring nobody making a dangerous crossing that day died in the process.

Beyond that moment, of course, the system – problematic as it is – will have taken over. These new eight asylum seekers were transported to a local police station, as per protocol. At the moment, we don’t know what will happen to them, or where they will be as they await determination of their status. Perhaps they will become Canadians; perhaps not. While the rest of us wait to learn of their fates, we will continue to wonder whether we are still accepting of others or not, and who might belong and who might not.

With any luck, we will conclude that when we look at that RCMP officer holding that child, we want to see two Canadians, not just one.


One photo, less than 1,000 words: What is a Canadian?

  1. Isn’t that a gorgeous photo?

    We couldn’t BUY this kind of good publicity!

    • Agree, open arms, instead open handcuffs.

  2. No answers here, but some searching questions.

  3. A vivid illustration of what humanity is all about. The remarkable and genuine smile of an RCMP officer exudes of love and compassion.
    Canada, a country to be truly proud of and to call it a home. Why would anyone harm such a blessed land under any circumstances is beyond me.

  4. Canada is different from the USA, Maclean’s is quite wrong to say we are nothing more than the mirror image of that country South of us. If we were you would see American fashion the RCMP shooting dead anyone crossing the border. Shame on Maclean’s for perpetuating such a negative image of Canada. As for the Motion 103 in Parliament, the Cons foment hate simply because they believe that will give them money and votes. Their brand of politics were rejected in 2015 end of story. Canada is the founder of the UNHCR and we have done a fantastic job welcoming refugees something that cannot be said of Trumpland.

    • But you do know that they are handcuffed just before they are put into the vehicle that takes them to get checked by our immigration people. I was quite shocked!!

      • That’s because they are technically taken into custody until their status can be investigated. Once they make their refugee claim formally, they are usually released from custody.
        It’s also standard practice, for safety reasons, to cuff anyone before you put them in the back of a police car.

        • Source please.

          • Emily, there are several other stories that show photos of the father being cuffed and placed in the back of a police car. The dad is grinning from ear to ear in the pictures, by the way.
            People who come across the border are arrested for not entering through a regulated border crossing. As soon as they say they plan to claim refugee status, the situation changes and they are referred to Immigration to have their claim determined. Immigration has 3 days to decide if they’re eligible to apply for refugee status.
            Note this isn’t a determination of their actual refugee claim but only if they are eligible to apply. The info about applying for status from within Canada, including eligibility criteria and the definition of ‘refugee’, is at:

      • Source please.

  5. I don’t see the picture as one “of a man relieved to complete a job he’d been sent to do” but one of a man, probably a dad himself, glad to see a child reaching freedom. That’s joy, not relief, in his face. The child would certainly have understood that.
    This is the same Canadian welcome that greeted the Syrian refugees at airports across the land last year to the True North, strong and free.

  6. Pretty disturbing the current narrative that’s being pushed through the media. The idea that there should be any vetting process, or any chance at all that refugee claimants be denied the ability to live here and have Canadian taxpayers fund their existence, is portrayed as some terrible thing that should make us feel collectively ashamed, some kind of stain on our national honour. Coming to this country is a privilege, not a right, yet left-wing propaganda outlets like this one try to assert the opposite. I think we should be extremely selective about who we let in and no, just because you jumped our border doesn’t make you a Canadian, and it doesn’t entitle you to handouts from actual Canadian taxpayers. I’d rather that we help these people in their own countries, but that seems to be at odds with the globalist agenda.

    • Listen up John-Boy

      Canada is obliged by UN treaty to take so many refugees every year.

      Immigrants are vetted….refugees are simply taken in.

      Supposedly Christian.

      Coming to Canada is not a privilege…..the Earth belongs to everyone.

    • John:
      These families coming over the border are refugee claimants. They are not yet admitted permanently to Canada but will have to go through hearings where they will have to prove that they are genuine refugees fleeing persecution in their home country. It’s by no means a sure thing that their claim will be successful and, if they fail, they are deported.
      It’s a long road from crossing the border to becoming Canadian citizens. The majority of them are hard-working people who will learn one or both of our languages and become contributing members of Canadian society.
      Remember that it’s just a lucky chance of the birth lottery that you ended up where you are and they were dealt the hand they got. It doesn’t mean you’re any better than them or more entitled to be here.