The most expensive burger in history

Kate Lunau on the ethics and implications of lab-grown meat


 

Scientist Dr. Mark Post poses with samples of in-vitro meat in a laboratory, at the University of Maastricht in the Netherlands on November 9, 2011. (Francois Lenoir/Reuters)

As long weekend revelers across Canada throw steaks and sausages on the grill, Dr. Mark Post was cooking up something different: a hamburger made of animal stem cells, grown in his lab at Maastricht University in the Netherlands.

The one little five-ounce patty took him years to perfect, at a cost of 300,000 euros, or more than $409,500 (donated by an anonymous investor), making it what must be the most expensive and labour-intensive sandwich patty in history. Some doubted it could be done. As the burger was unveiled in London—then bitten, chewed, swallowed and consumed, for all the world to see—Post’s burger was redefining “meat” as we know it. This is the food of the future.

Post, a medical doctor, has been attempting to create tissues in the lab for almost a decade. The applications are huge: engineered human tissues could be used to test drugs, for example, or to treat many diseases where the body wastes away.

To Post, the “food application” started out as an interesting side project, one that soon stole the spotlight from his other work. Meat for consumption is “in theory, much easier to grow,” he told Maclean’s in an interview in 2012. “The tissue does not need to physically integrate into the body. I considered it a closer goal to reach,” he says, “and a very important one.”

Indeed, the global appetite for meat is growing.

Livestock production already takes up 30 per cent of the land surface on our planet, says a 2006 United Nations report, producing more greenhouse gas emissions than all our cars and trucks, combined. According to Patrick O. Brown of Stanford University, eating one four-ounce hamburger is the equivalent of leaving a bathroom faucet running round-the-clock for a week. Developing nations are increasingly emulating the meat-heavy Western diet, and it isn’t sustainable. “We are heading towards a meat shortage worldwide,” Post says. Instead of producing beef, pork and poultry on massive industrial farms, in the near future, he predicts, we’ll be growing it in factories. And while this first hamburger was incredibly expensive to make, as techniques are perfected and lab-grown stem-cell burgers can be mass-produced, the cost will go down; one day it could be lower than the price of traditionally raised meat, which is expected to rise.

Of course, growing a minced hamburger patty—let alone a dense, fat-marbled steak—isn’t a simple task. Post and his team harvested stem cells from a cow’s muscle tissue, and bathed them in a special formula of nutrients. As these cells start to differentiate into muscle cells, they’re hooked to attachment points (Post has used Velcro) to create tiny strips of tissue, like a tendon. Eventually, they start to contract on their own. “The downside for animal lovers is that you still need animals,” a donor herd to provide stem cells, Post says. But compared to factory farming today, the number would be very small. If we grew all our meat in a lab, Post believes, the number of livestock worldwide could be reduced by a factor of one million—the equivalent of reducing 10 billion livestock animals on the planet to 10,000. This would free up land, water, and other resources, while making sure remaining livestock didn’t “suffer a death fraught with the issues of large-scale slaughter.”

Other than Post, only a handful of scientists are working on lab-grown meat; others believe the future lies in plant-based substitutes, ones so good they could fool even the most discerning palate, although Post maintains that we humans will always have an appetite for the real thing.

“Worldwide, the meat-eater population is going to grow. There’s no doubt about that,” he says.

Post’s hamburger is a powerful proof of concept, an important first step. Now we must unravel the implications of this one burger—for science, for health care, and for the food supply that feeds everyone on the planet.



 

The most expensive burger in history

  1. Well, first we’ll have to go through the standard ‘Yuck Factor’ stage, but eventually yes….this is what we’ll be eating.

    • Like many in the Western world, as I get older I’ve begun to develop ethical qualms about meat production, it’s impact on the environment, and the cruelty of abattoirs and feedlots. But also like most people I’m an obligate carnivore when presented with the opportunity and haven’t met a vegan yet who was a worthwhile human being. Laboratory meat would reconcile my divergent opinions.

      I think one day the ‘Yuck Factor’ will apply to someone who butchers and eats an animal, instead of eating grown meat.

      • Yeah, it’s difficult. I’ve often considered being a vegetarian….and then I read through the list of foods I would be allowed….beans, rice, pulses, nuts etc…blech. And I never cared for veggies until I could steam them, or eat them raw….as in my youth they were boiled into tasteless mush.

        I finally got it down to no sentient animals. Beef, lamb, chicken, duck, geese and seafood are okay…I don’t think I COULD give up lamb…but no pork, goat, octopi etc. Anything intelligent. This would also eliminate whale and dolphin….although I’ve never been offered any. LOL

        Vegans themselves are just annoying….and I honestly don’t think they’re particularly healthy. And vegans who don’t eat dairy should be smacked. LOL

        I believe in ‘everything in moderation’….including ‘diets’

        Yeah, lab meat would be a big help

  2. We covered this issue in The Vegan Option internet radio show – surveying both vegans and omnivores, talking to a Peta-funded lab meat scientist, and interviewing a philosopher who thought it has the potential to save the animals, and a vegan activist who thinks it’s a dreadful idea.

    If it’s of interest, you can listen online to Lab Meat: Can in vitro meat save the animals?.

    http://theveganoption.org/2012/04/03/lab-meat-nicholas-genovese-david-pearce-jordi-casamitjana/

  3. You definitely can’t beat this guys meat.

  4. This comment was deleted.

    • I agree you need help if you are not getting it now. Your language and grammar use also point to some problems, seriously get some help.

    • Finally something I could agree on other than your pessismistic rants—the unions suck!

    • Serious question: Do you have rabies?

  5. I would eat the $#!T out of that.

  6. If the world goes vegan or even vegetarian, then we are going to need a whole lot of chemical fertilizeers because we won’t have any natural ones. There’s a good reason why the first 9 millenia of farming included both plants and animals.

    • If we were vegan we’d still have animals, we just wouldn’t eat them.

      • We would have no need for current food animals so we would not keep them. Same as the automobile displaced the horse in our cities.

        • Sigh….there are more than food animals in the world

  7. No way will the lab make something as nutritious as millions of years of evolution made it. I find much of large scale animal husbandry abhorrent (visit a large commercial hog barn or chicken operation if you don’t believe me), but I’ll still eat those poor buggers before eating something out of a lab.

  8. NO! The teaching unions ensure
    that workers are represented in a greedy capitalist society. If it
    weren’t for unions, we teachers would be working for less than $2 a day.

    Dumb dumb conspiracy theorist. For anyone reading these posts which are slandering Martingrove Collegiate Vice Principal V ivian M avrou I hope that you
    realize these statements are not true and are posted by individuals for a
    reason unknown. I have worked with V ivian for a number of years and
    find her to be a great administrator. Now think, if any of these
    statements about her doing oral sex on a student in her car were true could TDSB really hide this from teachers, parents,
    students, the media or the police – absolutely not. I shudder to think
    what the purpose of these constant posts are. The posters sound mentally
    disturbed and I am afraid that they would not get psychiatric help for
    their mental retardation. Names of students have been posted – you as
    teachers must agree that this is horrible – imagine when these students
    and families Google their names and see that they have been pulled into a
    slanderous campaign, very sad for the students and those employees of
    TDSB that would stoop so low for their own advancement !

    Mary Gowans lost her teaching job because of online trolls who smeared her name.. Think- the male student made lies about Mary Gowans because Mary Gowans was already married and loved her husband she wouldn’t even let the student have an all nighter with her. And that was why the student made malicious accusations against Mary Gowans and sent 1,000 spam text messages which were stored in the phone company’s database………………………….