Blame the Showrunner?


In comments, Todd defends Marti Noxon:

The seventh season, which Whedon was much more involved in, reportedly, is a much bigger disaster, both storytelling-wise and in betraying some of the things the show stood for.

I actually agree that the seventh season of Buffy was worse than the sixth (the sixth had some terrible episodes, but the seventh season was stone-cold boring), but still, Marti Noxon was the showrunner for the seventh season as well, and she’s got to take blame for stuff like writing the “vampires can be drowned” episode.

But as he notes, if the creator of the show comes back and gets more involved, that doesn’t guarantee that the show will get better, and it may actually get worse. In the age when fans are actually aware of showrunners — used to be fans didn’t know the name of any executive producer other than Gene Roddenberry; now showrunners are minor celebrities — there’s a tendency for fans to connect a decline in quality to the absence or decreased involvement of the creator. It’s rarely that simple, because if creator has input into picking his/her successor, then he or she will probably wind up approving of the results.

So Simpsons fans spent the Mike Scully years lamenting that none of this would be happening if Matt Groening weren’t involved with Futurama and if the original writers were there, and then Futurama got canceled and Simpsons veteran Al Jean came back as showrunner, and the show eventually wound up having all the same problems over again. Because if Groening or James L. Brooks really hadn’t approved of the jockey-trolls stories, they’d have had the power to put a stop to them.


Blame the Showrunner?

  1. I blame whoever decided that Dawn was a good idea.

  2. Except the lamentable jockey-trolls story did have one of the great all around lines in Simpsons history when Comic Book guy pointed out that the Simpsons already had a horse, inviting us to remember what a great story “Lisa gets a Pony” was compared to the uh.. jockeys. I almost think that this was the writers saying that they gave up and could no longer come up with new ideas.

  3. I give Noxon co-blame for season seven, but, really, the show she wanted to write wasn’t the show that Buffy (for its first five seasons) WAS. She was brought in to do some of the soap-y angst-n-pain stuff, whereas Buffy was only about this, really, in a handful of episodes per season. When she was asked to bring the show back to basics in season seven, it ran counter to everything she wanted to be doing, I think, so we got a lot of uninspired plotting.

    Though I still maintain everything through the Watcher’s Council blowing up is actually pretty good set-up in that season and then the show falls apart because they just have no idea where they’re going to go with any of this.

  4. i liked season 6, a lot. The one I can’t stand is season 4 with the exception of Hush.

    I liked 2 and 3 and lots of 5. 6 was good, 1 was as good as it could have been and 7, well a bad buffy season is still better than most tv shows best seasons.

    Oh I forgot to write the cya, IMHO.

Sign in to comment.