Spying allegations put Canada-Brazil military ties at risk: experts

OTTAWA – A carefully cultivated military relationship with Brazil could be damaged by the unfolding spy drama involving Canada’s super-secret eavesdropping agency, defence and diplomacy experts say.

Since late spring, a platoon of Canadian soldiers has been embedded with a Brazilian army unit as part of the United Nations peacekeeping mission in Haiti.

The deployment is slated to run until Christmas, but the entire exercise has been considered an important bridge-building effort with South America’s biggest military power.

The Conservative government attempted to contain the damage Tuesday. Prime Minister Stephen Harper said he is “very concerned” and that Canadian officials are “reaching out very proactively” to their counterparts in Brazil.

But experts say the relationship of trust built up by the joint mission and over the last few years by the country’s top military commanders has been badly damaged.

The government in Sao Paulo actually sought out Canadian participation in the Haiti operation because of the country’s reputation as a peacekeeper, said Walter Dorn, a professor at the Canadian Forces Staff College in Toronto.

“This scandal will cause Brazil to have second thoughts about Canada as a reliable partner,” said Dorn, an authority in peacekeeping operations.

The Communications Security Establishment of Canada controversy could be especially problematic, considering the apparent targets, said Jean Daudelin, an associate professor at Carleton University’s Norman Paterson School of International Affairs.

She said “mistrust will pervade the relationship” not only because Brazil’s mining minister was tracked, but also because the electronic spy agency was tapping the phone of Paulo Cordeiro, a top diplomat who was Brazil’s ambassador to Canada and also served in Haiti.

Cordeiro was seen as “a good a friend of Canada,” said Daudelin. “Lots of things to patch up and, unlike in the case of the United States, no good reason on either side to invest much in doing so.”

An impact will definitely be felt on the trade front, said Dorn.

Asked about the unfolding controversy on Monday, Defence Minister Rob Nicholson said he doesn’t believe military relations — in particular the Haiti mission — will suffer because of the allegations.

“I believe our collaboration and friendship will continue on all aspects,” he said.

The mission is “part of a wide range of activities that we have with Brazil and I have every confidence that will continue.”

If anything, the quarrel means any notion of extending the partnership in Haiti has been put on ice, said Dorn.

But the officer in charge of Canada’s overseas deployments said no extension has been contemplated, and while it was a useful exercise, the three dozen troops — members of the Royal 22e Regiment — will be home by Christmas.

In an interview just before the spying allegations surfaced, Lt.-Gen. Stuart Beare said the mission “has been going incredibly well from the Brazilian perspective” and from the United Nations point of view.

The Canadians are embedded with Brazil’s 44th Motorized Infantry battalion and have been conducting patrols on the impoverished, earthquake-ravaged island.

The idea of teaming up with Brazil, the largest contributor to the UN stabilization mission in Haiti, floated around National Defence headquarters for two years and was pitched as a way to increase bilateral ties with the emerging economic power.

Beare said the Canadians have learned a lot, but he acknowledged it was time-consuming to manage such a tiny mission.

“The motivation to be there wasn’t limited to a contribution to (the UN mission). It was to partner up with a military partner in the hemisphere and there’s other ways to partner … beyond contributing troops to a United Nations mission,” Beare told The Canadian Press.

“Will it become a norm? No. Will it be an option (in the future)? It’s always an option.”

There are roughly 8,800 international troops in Haiti and an additional 1,200 police officers conducting training under the United Nations flag.

Looking for more?

Get the Best of Maclean's sent straight to your inbox. Sign up for news, commentary and analysis.