Supreme Court won't hear appeal from municipalities liable in car crash

OTTAWA – The Supreme Court of Canada will not hear the appeal of two Ontario municipalities found liable for a crash that left two teenaged sisters in wheelchairs for the rest of their lives.

Shannon and Erica Deering, then 19 and 16, suffered catastrophic spinal injuries when their car left the road on their way to a movie theatre on Aug. 10, 2004.

The horrific crash left the Port Perry, Ont., sisters quadriplegic and gave rise to $30 million in claims as well as an eight-year legal battle with the City of Oshawa and Scugog Township.

In 2010, an Ontario Superior Court found Shannon Deering to be one-third liable for the crash, and the municipalities — located east of Toronto — liable for the balance.

The municipalities appealed, but the Appeal Court found they had failed to ensure the road was safe and therefore mainly at fault even though the driver was speeding.

Today’s decision by the Supreme Court puts an end to the municipalities’ latest challenge. As usual, the country’s top court gave no reason for its ruling.

Shannon Deering’s lawyer said the sisters “gasped with delight” when they heard the news.

“I could feel their relief over the phone,” Roger Oakley said. “It’s the single best day since they were injured.”

Oakley said the two women have been living off their accident benefits with help from relatives while the ongoing court challenge kept them from accessing the damages they have been awarded.

Now, the lawyer said he expects “the cheques to be cut” by the end of January.

The sisters’ total claims exceed $30 million, but details of discussions around damages to be paid by the city were not disclosed.

Looking for more?

Get the Best of Maclean's sent straight to your inbox. Sign up for news, commentary and analysis.