Putin foe Alexei Navalny found guilty of fraud, brother jailed

The anti-corruption campaigner was found guilty of fraud and given a suspended sentence of three and a half years on Tuesday, while his brother was sent to prison

MOSCOW – Alexei Navalny, the anti-corruption campaigner who is a leading foe of Russian President Vladimir Putin, was found guilty of fraud and given a suspended sentence of three and a half years on Tuesday, while his brother was sent to prison.

The verdict was scheduled for next month, but the court session was abruptly moved forward to the day before New Year’s Eve, the main holiday in Russia, leading to speculation that authorities wanted to head off protests. More than 30,000 had previously signed up on Facebook to rally outside the Kremlin to protest what they called an unlawful trial.

Navalny and his younger brother Oleg were convicted of defrauding a French cosmetics company and given the same sentence as each other, but Oleg’s was not suspended. The court also fined each of them 500,000 rubles (about $8,800) and ordered them to pay some 4 million rubles ($77,000) in damages.

Oleg Navalny, the father of two small children and a former executive of the state-owned postal service, has never played a role in the Russian opposition movement and his imprisonment could echo the Soviet-era practice of punishing the relatives of inconvenient people.

“Aren’t you ashamed of what you’re doing? You want to punish me even harder?” Alexei Navalny shouted out as Judge Yelena Korobchenko handed down the sentence for his brother.

Alexei briefly entered the metal cage that his brother was put into after the verdict and appeared to be holding back tears.

“This is the most disgusting and vile of all possible verdicts,” Alexei Navalny said outside the court.

“The government isn’t just trying to jail its political opponents – we’re used to it, we’re aware that they’re doing it – but this time they’re destroying and torturing the families of the people who oppose them,” he said, and called for a protest Tuesday evening.

The suspended sentence means that it could be converted into a prison term at any moment if Alexei Navalny offends again, although this will be still up to the court to decide.

Navalny has been under house arrest since February and his lawyer Vadim Kobzev told The Associated Press that he will remain there until all appeals are exhausted, which could take months.

The trial seemed to be full of inconsistencies and loopholes.

The company involved, Yves Rocher, wrote a complaint to investigators, but its representatives have insisted throughout the trial that there never were any damages. The French executive who wrote the complaint also left Russia shortly afterward and never attended the hearings.

The prosecutors insisted that the brothers forced the company “into disadvantageous contracts” and defrauded it of 26 million rubles (about $440,000).

The brothers had both arrived at the courtroom with luggage, indicating they expected to be immediately imprisoned.

Navalny, a lawyer and popular blogger, rose to prominence with his investigations of official corruption and played a leading role in organizing massive anti-Putin demonstrations in Moscow in 2011 and 2012.

In a 2013 trial in a different criminal case, he was found guilty of embezzlement and sentenced to prison, but he was released the next day after thousands of people protested in the streets of Moscow. He was then handed a suspended sentence and finished a strong second in Moscow’s mayoral election in September 2013.

The verdict and sentencing add to anxiety over the Russian economy’s plunge this year. At midday, the Russian benchmark index MICEX was down about 2 per cent.

Russian tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky, who spent 10 years in jail before he was pardoned last year, dismissed the verdict as Putin’s revenge for Navalny’s activism.

Khodorkovsky said in a statement that he is “not even surprised that Putin and his entourage are capable of vile tricks, deception, forgery and manipulation – they are not capable of anything else.”

New York-based Human Rights Watch said the verdict sends a message “to independent voices to expect a harsher crackdown in 2015.”

Still, some Russian officials suggested the sentence was too light and should be appealed by prosecutors, which is permitted under Russian law. Mikhail Markelov, a prominent parliament member from the United Russia party that is Putin’s power base, told the news agency Tass that “everything should be done to achieve reconsideration of this sentence.”

Navalny’s supporters are expected to rally outside the Kremlin Tuesday evening in a rare unsanctioned protest.

Looking for more?

Get the best of Maclean's sent straight to your inbox. Sign up for news, commentary and analysis.