The trouble with tax-free savings accounts

Daniel Tencer reviews two new studies into the public policy implications of tax-free savings accounts, which were introduced by the Harper government in 2008.

While one in three British taxpayers now have a tax-free account, that drops to as low as one in 20 among low-income earners, the study found. “The introduction of ISAs has done little, if anything, to break down the barriers to saving faced by low-income individuals,” the study says. Not surprisingly, the main reason for not participating in the accounts was a lack of money to put in them…

Meanwhile a study from UBC economics professor Kevin Milligan, also published at the CTF, estimates that the government could have a hard time raising revenue as TFSAs grow older and larger. Milligan notes that, because TFSAs accumulate over time, eventually Canadians will have a large portion — if not all — of their assets sheltered from taxation altogether.

The current issue of the Canadian Tax Journal includes two other papers on TFSAs: one from Jonathan Rhys Kesselman on possible reforms and one from Finn Poschmann on reasons for expanding TFSAs.

Looking for more?

Get the best of Maclean's sent straight to your inbox. Sign up for news, commentary and analysis.