Editorial

We all share this grief

Our editorial: On our cover this month, we offer a Farsi expression of condolence to illustrate a collective spirit of national devastation after the downing of Flight 752 in Tehran

The tragic downing of Ukrainian International Airlines Flight 752 over Tehran in early January offers a sober opportunity to consider what it means to be a Canadian today. And, while what can be found amid the horror is mostly unspeakable pain, its aftermath also provides a hopeful glimpse of a changing nation.

Of the 176 aboard the plane, 57 were Canadian citizens and another 29 were permanent residents. Almost all the passengers were on their way to Canada, and most were of Iranian origin. The flight was a physical reminder of the 210,000-strong Iranian diaspora in Canada. And the links are becoming stronger: last year, Iran was among the top 10 source countries for new permanent residents to Canada (the first step to becoming a citizen) and now accounts for more admissions, on an annual basis, than the United Kingdom. This is how Canada changes.

FLIGHT 752: A family torn apart
ESSAY: ‘Canada cries for humanity’
PHOTOS: A nation’s loss—Victims of Flight 752

The victims of Flight 752 are equally noteworthy for their impressiveness. Two students in Saint Mary’s University’s master of finance program are among the dead, as are two engineering students at Dalhousie. Three students from the University of Ottawa. Four from Western University. Six from the University of Toronto. Ten faculty members and students from the University of Alberta. Many were returning home to Canada after spending the Christmas break in Iran. “The people we lost in the plane truly represented the smartest young researchers in the entire world,” Neda Maghbouleh, a sociology professor at the University of Toronto who studies Iranian migration through the U.S. and Canada, told Reuters after the tragedy. “It is an unspeakable loss.”

Here again we can see Canada playing the role of sanctuary. The number of study permits issued by Canada to Iranian citizens has nearly tripled since 2016, largely due to recent U.S. sanctions against international students from Iran and other Muslim countries.

The front and back cover of the March 2020 issue of Maclean’s

Finally, the plane crash offers an opportunity to reflect on how Canada itself reacts to tragedies. When 329 people, mostly Canadians of Indian origin, were killed in the 1985 Air India bombing off the coast of Ireland, there was no immediate, nationwide outpouring of grief. Then-prime minister Brian Mulroney actually phoned India’s prime minister Rajiv Gandhi to express his condolences, when it should have been the other way around. It has taken several decades, and an apology from former prime minister Stephen Harper, to properly position this event in the national consciousness as the deadliest terrorist attack ever perpetrated against Canadians.


‘They wanted a simple life’: Remembering Razgar Rahimi, Farideh Gholami and Jiwan Rahimi

‘Her heart was like the ocean’: Remembering Niloufar Sadr

‘They were both go-getters’: Remembering Arvin Morattab and Aida Farzaneh


This time, as flags flew at half-mast across the country and vigils flickered at university campuses and city squares from coast to coast to coast (in Iqaluit, too), the Prime Minister swiftly and appropriately described the accident as a “terrible loss suffered by Canadians of Iranian origin, but also the entire Canadian fabric.” Added Trudeau: “The country is gutted.” And: “While no words will erase your pain, I want you to know that an entire country is with you.”

On our cover this month, we offer a Farsi expression of condolence. Mâ Hamé dar in gham shareek Hasteem is literally translated as “we are all partners in this grief” or “we all share this grief.” We have chosen these words over other equally moving Iranian expressions of loss because, together with the Farsi speakers and experts we consulted, we thought it best illustrated a collective spirit of national devastation.

A condolence for this grieving country, Canadians all.