Uncategorized

Parker? Spitzer? I Hardly...

In the Charlie Sheen post, I was saying that instead of shutting down, his show should get rid of him and do an old-fashioned retool. It won’t, but another show will: CNN’s Parker/Spitzer is getting rid of Kathleen Parker and revamping as a Spitzer vehicle called “In the Arena.

The show needs a revamp, as it was incredibly boring and Spitzer was the less boring of the two hosts; also, the format was just awful — it seemed to want to be a throwback to “civility” (a word that is quite rightly becoming a punchline) in an era of increased pugnaciousness and political polarization. It had no point of view, and an opinion show without a point of view is pointless. That’s why Fox News continues to thrive while CNN, with no identity, and MSNBC, with almost no identity, struggle.

CNN’s inability to take a point of view on anything means it can’t survive in today’s TV news ecosystem; there are such deep divisions on issues that when you try to find a nonexistent middle ground, you wind up looking irrelevant. Fox News, obviously, does not have this problem. Even their one stealth liberal journalist, the strangely out-of-place Shep Smith, is willing to be blunt in a way that most “liberal” cable personalities (except Rachel Maddow, whom he’s been accused by eagle-eyed Fox fans of echoing in the clip below) almost never are.

Looking for more?

Get the best of Maclean's sent straight to your inbox. Sign up for news, commentary and analysis.