The power—and the violence—of being an Indigenous trans woman

In the Anishinaabe worldview, being Two-Spirited is holy. In Western culture, being transgender is anything but. A poet digs into the differences


 
Gwen Benaway.

Gwen Benaway.

The first person to name my gender was my Anishinaabemowin (Ojibway) language teacher. A fluent speaker in all dialects of Anishinaabemowin and a residential school survivor, he looked at me one day and said, “You have a woman’s spirit.”

His nonchalance about my gender reflects my culture’s understanding of my identity. Indigenous trans women have always been an important part of Anishinaabe (Ojibway) worldview, a natural and sacred expression of Indigenous womanhood. When the Jesuits first arrived in our traditional lands, they were shocked at the casual integration of Indigenous trans women in Anishinaabe society. To us, being trans is normal.

It is common to see Indigenous trans women as a modern creation, but we are a sacred expression of our nation’s worldviews and sovereignty. In the teachings I know from elders within my nation, Indigenous trans women have always existed in Anishinaabe society. There are traditional legends about us as well as specific ceremonial roles for Indigenous trans women. We were not separated from other Indigenous women, but were valued as equal to cisgender Indigenous women. Often we took on roles related to community caretaking and nurturing, working as negotiators, orators, and community planners. Within our communities, we were valued as romantic partners because of many responsibilities we carried.

The last 150 years of colonization—residential schools, forced Christianization, the outlawing of traditional ceremonies—have tried to destroy and erase Indigenous trans women from our culture. In some cases, Indigenous trans women were openly murdered by colonizers, creating a cycle of violence which follows us to this day. The third trans woman murdered in 2017 was an Indigenous trans woman in the United States. Many of the names on the lists of murdered and missing Indigenous women belong to Indigenous trans women.

I walk inside the violence of being an Indigenous trans woman every day. I have heard the stories of older Indigenous trans women who were driven from their communities because of their gender. I watch younger Indigenous women struggle to maintain their community ties while transitioning. When I first transitioned, I lost some of my closest Indigenous friends because of transphobia. We are caught in lethal crossfire of racism, colonization, transphobia and misogyny. There are very few public Indigenous women who are visible, engaged in their communities, and celebrated as leaders for Indigenous cultures.

The best way I know to explain this intersection is through a recent experience I had in my dating life. Dating as a trans woman is always dangerous and dehumanizing, but dating as an Indigenous trans woman is more complicated. I was casually dating a Euro-Canadian guy when he suddenly broke up with me. Right before he launched into the formal “we need to break up” conversation, he talked for ten minutes about how much he loved narratives of European explorers. He highlighted their bravery, going into unknown lands and discovering new worlds.

I pointed out that those unknown lands and new worlds were already known and familiar to someone. “It doesn’t end well for the people that the explorers found,” I said. “It usually results in genocide.” He paused for a moment and then nodded: “Yeah, I guess.” I could feel my stomach drop as soon as he starting romanticizing European conquest, the nausea I’ve come to associate with being forced to listen to someone’s racism.

I was the first trans girl he had ever dated. I’d been upfront about my pre-operation surgery status from the beginning. He told me repeatedly that he was comfortable with my gender, including during our breakup. Later, I saw that he changed his online-dating profile’s sexual orientation from “heteroflexible”—shortform for men who will date trans women—to “straight” after he broke up with me.

One of my friends tried to comfort me by saying that I’d helped him discover his sexuality. But no girl wants to be an experiment or a learning process. I am constantly engaged by men who see me as a curiosity or a fetish, not a whole person. This replays the colonial narrative again, but in intimate terms. Now, I am my ancestors again. I am the conquered woman that he discovered and discarded. I was the unknown land to him.

This is the intersection of being Indigenous and trans. Right before I experience a deeply intimate expression of transphobia, I enter a space of racism and colonial thought. Both forms of violence are linked. Within my traditional culture, there is no fear or aversion to trans women as romantic partners. We were viewed as valuable in Anishinaabe culture, because we were often surrogate parents to orphaned children and worked to support our communities. Western culture views trans women as sexual curiosities—women who threaten their male partner’s masculinity and are seen as lesser than other women.

For me, it’s a primary example of how colonization has degraded the inherent humanity of Indigenous trans women. Romantic rejection is painful, yes—but imagine if that rejection is grounded in Western society’s judgment and conception of your gender as invalid. My body must survive transphobia, colonization, and misogyny. Even when I win against one oppression, I lose to another.

There is more to being an Indigenous trans woman than the oppression we face. There have been so many painful moments in my transition, but I am constantly strengthened by reflecting on the power of my ancestors, Indigenous women who have survived genocide. Indigenous womanhood is a beautiful and fierce love. In Anishinaabe culture, we come from the waters of our land and carry many responsibilities; we are seen as the spiritual and intellectual hearts of our nations. This is a gift, no matter how much the world tries to devalue us.

Whenever I feel the shame that other people place on my body, I look up old photographs of Indigenous trans women. Those women, often unnamed and erased within our histories, remind me that my body is holy in my culture. I was born into this spirit. When an Indigenous trans woman walks in the world, she holds all of her ancestors up with her.

I hope that the recent conversations around reconciliation in Canada recognize that the involvement of Indigenous Two-Spirit people, including Indigenous trans women, is central to that work. Our Indigenous political and ceremonial leaders need to push for the inclusion of Indigenous trans women in the healing of our communities.

We often forget that the genocide of Indigenous peoples in Canada began with the oppression of Indigenous women. The state aimed its violence towards our hearts as a people, including the murder and suppression of Indigenous Two-Spirit peoples and trans women. To restore our balance as nations, we need to lift up Indigenous Two-Spirit and trans women again. Sometimes I worry that we forget that the models of gender and sexuality we have in Canada come from violence. Everyone in Canada—trans or cis, straight or queer, Indigenous or non-Indigenous—is harmed by this.

I often think back to the words of my language teacher. His casual acceptance of my gender is a reminder that my womanhood as an Indigenous trans woman is defined by my spirit, not my body. I have been on hormones for almost a year and plan on having gender confirmation surgery, but these are just medical decisions I’ve made to make my life easier. My identity as an Indigenous trans woman is rooted in creation. With that connection comes pain, but also a deep strength. It’s time for Indigenous and non-Indigenous communities alike to honour and value our contributions as Indigenous trans women.

Gwen Benaway is a trans girl poet of Anishinaabe and Métis descent who has published two collections of poetry, Ceremonies for the Dead and Passage, and will be publishing her third collection, Holy Wild, with BookThug in 2018.


 

The power—and the violence—of being an Indigenous trans woman

  1. I’m excited to hear your voice, Gwen. Thanks so much for sharing a bit about your experience, your struggles, your hopes and strengths. The diversity of humanity is a divine and beautiful thing, and we are all richer when we hear from wonderful brave people like you.

  2. Thank you for your bravery and courage.
    Lots of love and hugs, and I look forward to more writing from you!