The case of Marlene Giersdorf -

The case of Marlene Giersdorf


Diane Finley talks to the Post about the case of Marlene Giersdorf, the Prince Edward Island woman who has been cut off from EI benefits.

Q And what’s your reaction to what you’ve seen so far?

A Personal circumstances will always be taken into consideration in determining someone’s eligibility. For example, if they don’t have transportation to another community where a job is, that will be taken into consideration. Child care responsibilities and costs will be taken into consideration because we want to make sure that when people work, they’re better off than when they don’t. That being said, Service Canada officials can only take into consideration the information that they have. If the claimant doesn’t provide all of the relevant individual circumstances, then Service Canada can only go with the information they have.

Q In this particular situation, do you know if the individual did provide that information to Service Canada?

A Service Canada has made multiple attempts to talk with her, to review her file, to go over the options, to get all of the information. But it had no success in reaching her and I really encourage her to get in touch with them.

Ms. Giersdorf, meanwhile, says she’s tried to contact Service Canada and also that she’s been protesting just outside a Service Canada office. And then there is bit of back-and-forth.

Last week, Queen said there were half a dozen jobs in Montague the woman could have applied for; however, Geirsdorf said they were all beyond her qualifications. Officials also say there is more to the EI case than meets the eye, but can’t discuss it.


The case of Marlene Giersdorf

  1. So, she can’t afford a ph or a car, she’s standing right outside the door of manpower [ how much did that little bit of rebranding cost us i wonder?] and they still can’t find her! Maybe they should send her a gps tracking device, buy her a ph?…or just maybe someone should like go down to her and invite her in for a talk? There are times when even i wonder if putting govt in charge of anything isn’t a bad idea after all.

    • Harpers govt….can’t find its tushy with 2 hands and a mirror.

    • They need a Seven Point Plan to initiate an Action Plan to locate her.

  2. She’s in a Liberal riding, IOW she’s hooped. Joan Crockett warned us about not having a
    Con as our MP.

  3. Hey Marlene. I just looked online and saw a job vacancy in MONTAGUE. Immediate start. Breakfast cook. Permanent. Full time. 30 hours/week. $11.00/hour. Why can’t you take this job?

  4. “Officials also say there is more to the EI case than meets the eye, but can’t discuss it.”
    … And the campaign to discredit her begins.