Trump wants 'massive' NAFTA renegotiation

'Big isn't a good enough word,' Donald Trump tells magazine regarding his vision for a revamp of NAFTA

Barton NAFTA2

WASHINGTON – President Donald Trump says he’s ready to start a major renegotiation of the North American Free Trade Agreement, now that his trade czar is poised to achieve a long-awaited confirmation by the U.S. Senate.

The upper chamber voted 81-15 to impose closure Thursday on the nomination of Robert Lighthizer, which indicates that after a few more days of debate he’ll almost certainly win a final vote and be in place next week.

The president told an interview with The Economist that he intends to proceed quickly thereafter: Trump intends to file a 90-day notice with Congress, work with it on negotiating priorities, and start talks with Canada and Mexico later this year.

RELATED: Support for NAFTA weakest in U.S., says Pew

“The clock starts ticking (with Lighthizer’s confirmation),” Trump told the magazine. The administration has begun signalling that it wants significant changes in a range of areas, including dairy, lumber, automobiles, pharmaceuticals and the dispute-resolution system.

Trump interjected when an interviewer suggested it sounds like he wants a big renegotiation.

“Big isn’t a good enough word,” the president replied.


But that desire for a “massive” renegotiation is butting up against the mundane realities of the political calendar. The U.S. and Mexico have both expressed a desire to get a deal by early next year, before the Mexican election – but few observers believe a substantive renegotiation is possible within a few months.

Trump repeated the story in that interview of how he almost withdrew from NAFTA last month. It’s a story he’s told several times.

MORE: When Trudeau called Trump: The story of the call that saved NAFTA

He described an amazing coincidence: Both Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, and Mexico’s Enrique Pena Nieto, called him one after the other, and both told him almost the same exact thing, urging him to reconsider.

“I have a very good relationship with Justin and a very good relationship with the president of Mexico,” Trump said.

“It was an amazing thing. They called separately 10 minutes apart. I just put down the phone with the president of Mexico when the prime minister of Canada called. And they both asked almost identical questions: ‘We would like to know if it would be possible to negotiate as opposed to a termination.’

And I said, ‘Yes, it is. Absolutely.’ So we did that and we’ll start.“

There’s a simple explanation for that coincidence: It wasn’t a coincidence.

Trump’s own son-in-law Jared Kushner set up the Trudeau call.

Around 6 p.m. on April 26, Kushner phoned a prime ministerial aide, told her there was an immediate window to speak with Trump, and she conveyed the news to Trudeau. Sources from both countries have confirmed that Kushner facilitated the call. In the White House version, Kushner was helping out, responding to a request earlier in the day from the Canadians to speak.

An open door provides a glimpse into a holding cell used for questioning on the American side of the Peace Bridge border patrol crossing in Buffalo, NY on March 24, 2017. (Photograph by Cole Garside)

An open door provides a glimpse into a holding cell used for questioning on the American side of the Peace Bridge border patrol crossing in Buffalo, NY on March 24, 2017. (Photograph by Cole Garside)

One source familiar with the thinking of both governments offered a theory for what’s happening: Trump wanted to take credit, before his 100th day in office, for forcing Canada and Mexico into a renegotiation.

The source said the governments of Canada and Mexico did the exact same thing as some companies like Ford and Japan’s SoftBank – they let Trump take credit for things they already intended to do.

In the case of the companies, it was building U.S. facilities. In the case of Canada and Mexico, it’s renegotiating NAFTA – which both countries had repeatedly stated they were ready for.

“That’s what everybody’s doing,” said the insider.

“(People are saying), ‘We’re gonna let Trump have the announcement – so he gets credit for it.’… They’ve decided, if they need to give him some victories, as long as it suits us – fine…

“As long as they’re not actually, in reality, getting screwed, he can say whatever he wants.”

RELATED: Will Canada and Mexico stick together on NAFTA?

A binational business group suggests one future way this could happen: on regulatory co-operation.

Canada is already working with the U.S. to eliminate red tape on products. Now that Trump is looking to slash two regulations for every one he creates, Canada could just hand him the credit.

“President Trump is eager for some wins. Canada can help provide him with one, while also advancing its own interests,” Maryscott Greenwood of the Canadian-American Business Council wrote in a Policy Options article.

“The Canadian government could present the United States with a proposal for aligning a particular set of regulations. This would represent a bilateral victory for what is at the moment a U.S.-only effort to cut regulatory red tape.”

Looking for more?

Get the best of Maclean's sent straight to your inbox. Sign up for news, commentary and analysis.